Skip to content
TARDIS Guide
illyriashade56

illyriashade56 has submitted 28 reviews and received 15 likes

Review of The Four Doctors by illyriashade56

4 January 2025

This review contains spoilers!

Love that scene at the end where all of them are stuck in a room with each other and none of them are enjoying it.


Review of Last Christmas by illyriashade56

24 December 2024

I always have a lot of fun with this episode. It's silly, it's a bit convoluted, and it's got some super fun bits to it. It's probably one of my favorite earlier Capaldi episodes.


Review of In the Blood by illyriashade56

23 December 2024

This review contains spoilers!

This story lives rent free in my head and once again proves Jenny Colgan really, really knows how to write these two.

Ten is a bit of a dork, Donna is just a little bit of a loser, and there's some funny bits (like the entire sequence on the plane where Donna misses Ten being attacked because she's watching a movie) and some genuinely heartfelt moments (like Donna marching off into the jungle to try and find the Doctor after the plane crashes), as well as some completely and utterly horrific moments (like the fate of everyone at the monastary, or Donna succumbing to the infection), and it's all just so much fun.

Also it was kind of fun to see Gully again after Time Reaver.


Review of Partners in Crime by illyriashade56

23 December 2024

Partners in Crime is always one of my favorite episodes to rewatch because it's brilliantly directed, Catherine Tate and David Tennant are hysterical, and it really sets up everything that happens over the course of season 4 and makes it so much more satisfying when everything wraps up.

RTD hit his stride with season 4 and this opener is no exception in my opinion.


Review of The Runaway Bride by illyriashade56

23 December 2024

I adore this episode, and it's one of my favorite episodes of Doctor Who ever. It introduces one of my favorite characters of all time in anything ever in Donna, and it's just so silly.

Ten is mopey and sad and wet and pathetic and it's incredibly funny and touching to see someone like Donna (self-absorbed, forceful, and very keen on being a nuisance, but ultimately a good person with a big heart) break through the shell of his grief a little bit and unintentionally save him from himself.

Catherine Tate and David Tennant have fantastic chemistry and it's always so nice to go back and rewatch this knowing that that's why we ended up getting a full season of Donna as a companion. They just bounce off of each other so well and it's delightful.


Review of Twice Upon a Time by illyriashade56

22 December 2024

At first I had a grudge against this episode for what they did to my favorite gremlin old man the First Doctor, but I rewatched it with the explanation from the novelization in mind (that One was just doing that to annoy Twelve) and it became ten times funnier and also very enjoyable. It's a fun episode, even if it's very uncharitable towards the early show and the time period it was written in.


Review of The Creeping Death by illyriashade56

22 December 2024

This review contains spoilers!

If I had a nickel for every story that featured a dinosaur skeleton on a rampage as a plot point I'd have two nickels, which isn't a lot but it's weird that it happened twice. Especially cause Ten sometimes feels like Harry Dresden if he was an alien and constantly high on caffeine.

Also, Donna wearing the Doctor's coat. That is all.


Review of One Mile Down by illyriashade56

22 December 2024

This review contains spoilers!

I have many, many thoughts about this episode for a lot of reasons that I can't really put into words at this moment, so I will instead focus on the fact that Ten was mortified that Donna was wearing crocs to this adventure.


Review of Technophobia by illyriashade56

22 December 2024

This review contains spoilers!

I love these idiots so much it's unreal. It's so fun hearing them banter again.

Highlight of the audio was Donna having the time of her life destroying shit with a bulldozer.


Review of Time Reaver by illyriashade56

22 December 2024

This review contains spoilers!

Jenny Colgan the grip you have on me with your Ten and Donna stories is unimaginable.

Gully is incredibly hard to understand sometimes due to the effects but he's still a really fun villain and I enjoyed him.

I adore how Jenny writes these two and how dynamic and slightly chaotic the story is, and all in all it's a very fun adventure.

I think a common mistake people make when writing the Doctor is making him super cool and competent, but Jenny understands that he's actually a bit of a dork and a loser and it adds so much charm and nuance to his character. I think about Ten putting the backgammon board in a time lock because he was upset Donna was beating him at least once a month it's so so funny.


Sorting, filtering, and pagination, coming soon!