This one is very much a Story I enjoy a lot while listening but after sitting on it, it feels very messy at best, ehhh at worst.
I like some stuff with Ace’s Character. I liked Liam, he worked surprisingly well, and it’s a shame he wasn’t used again. I liked the Setting and the Music is stellar…
…but it does handle some subject matters a bit poorly. While I can see the intention of it being overall messy, I don’t think it quite worked for me as much looking back. Especially disappointing since Lidster would write plenty of standout things, as his debut it offers some great Ideas executed decent to poorly.

📝5/10 = MIXED!

Thworping through time and space, one adventure at a time! This time: they took a pill in Ibiza.

With The Rapture, Big Finish goes for another experimental approach for a Doctor Who story, as evidenced by the opening scene pretending to be a radio program and the setting being the ultimate party island of Ibiza, complete with clubbing, drugs, alcohol, and the like. This memorable setting and the constant flow of club music we hear in the background instantly help The Rapture stand out.

This story also mixes in God’s heralds, or his angels, who are on the island to judge everyone’s souls. This brings a strange quasi-religious element to this but also adds effective tension. The overall atmosphere in this audio makes me suspect that Big Finish tried to go for a Virgin New Adventures approach with this story by going a bit experimental and a bit mature with it.

Sadly, this story turns very messy and overly ambitious partway through Part 2, mostly down to the sound design. It’s difficult to follow, but also oddly eerie and bizarre. Things improve slightly in the last part, though, and The Rapture certainly makes for a different experience that stays with you for a while after listening.

The Doctor feels somewhat forgotten here, but Sylvester McCoy is in great form. Sophie Aldred is also great, but Ace is unusually angry and annoyed throughout this. All this nonsense of her wanting to call herself McShane now just feels stupid.

A big part of Ace's story sees her come face to face with her younger brother, who’s revealed in a nice twist in Part 2. I look forward to hearing where this development is taken in future audios.

The supporting cast’s performances (mostly the ones voicing the partygoers) frequently sound unnatural and wooden, and that’s distracting.

The Monthly Adventures #036 - “The Rapture" by Joseph Lidster

There are a few Who writers who stand above all others, a few Who writers who pretty much always deliver quality stories, a few Who writers whose presence in a range will cause buyers to throw any amount of money at a release to get it. One of those few writers is Joseph Lidster. Renowned and revered in equal measure, Lidster is an immensely popular author still writing for Doctor Who to this day who has had his name attached to just about every range you could think of, from The Monthly Adventures, to Torchwood, to Bernice Summerfield, and it all began here, in a blistering rave of odd ideals and a fundamentally messy story.

Ace wants a break. Using her old name and determined to live a normal life, just for a day, she’s been taken to Ibiza by the Doctor, to take part in the new, hit rave everybody’s talking about: The Rapture. But not everything’s right at the Rapture; for the owners are planning something big and deadly, and vacationing college student Liam just so happens to have Ace’s picture in his coat pocket.

(CONTAINS SPOILERS)

Lidster is a writer who is near unrivalled when it comes to one thing: character work. We’ll hit some of his best stories as we progress through the Main Range, which boast some of Doctor Who’s greatest character pieces, but The Rapture itself is nothing to sneer at. It has a whole lot of problems, which I will get on to, but I have to come out and praise Lidster’s greatest qualities, which all shine here. Front and centre is Ace (or McShane for a few audios but I sure as hell won’t be calling her by that misguided choice), who, on a break from travelling with the Doctor, meets none other than her estranged brother. Such a big introduction to canon feels like it shouldn’t work, but Lidster manages to mould the situation enough so that it feels natural and allows this to become a very touching reunion for these two characters. I’m actually quite sad we never got to see Liam again after this because he was a genuinely very sweet character and that paired well with Ace and felt like a really good way to see more intricacies of her personality. As for the audio’s other defining factor - the music - I really dig it. Jim Mortimore is once again leading the soundtrack and has, this time around, given us a score of house music and dance pieces that not only really help to build the setting but also double as actually pretty good bits of music, especially the remixed intro theme that sadly seems to cut off early at the beginning of each part. Another thing I felt was significantly special about this story was the editing, something I haven’t really touched on as of yet in these reviews. The Rapture takes a very unique approach to intercut scenes and has lines flow into one another, a character will say something that’ll be relevant in the scene it cuts to, or a line will be finished by another person in another place and with this technique, Lidster at one point manages to interlock three scenes in what I consider the highlight moment of the audio, especially with Caitriona having the world’s jazziest drug trip, flying through the sky as Sylvester McCoy growls into a microphone about being the “sandman”.

However, for as much nuanced character building and psychedelic wonders there are, I can’t deny that The Rapture isn’t very good. Lidster’s strengths clearly lie in character and, because of that, he can often really struggle with the story. This whole script is messy, and that’s the only word I can think of to adequately describe it; it’s littered with problems that all just pile on top of each other to make for a somewhat disheartening time. Our antagonists, Gabriel and Jude, aren’t particularly threatening or empathetic, simply just there to create the story, I wasn’t too interested in their pasts and both turned out to have very little to them conceptually, just escapees from a dimensional war who are using religious imagery to trick one of them into forgetting his PTSD (that actually sounds a lot more interesting than it is on paper). They’re not terrible, they’re just not enough to hold up a story. Also, I think that acting in this audio is, on the whole, pretty bad. Chief among them is Caitriona ; Anne Bird really can’t do drunk acting well. However, pretty much everybody phones in their performance at points, in particular during rave scenes. I don’t doubt that it’s hard to recreate the passion of a nightclub in a silent audio booth but the undeniably forced performances make all the moments set in The Rapture near impossible to sit through. And then there’s the whole thing about depression. See, the character of Caitriona is described as being a “manic depressive”, and mental health struggles are pretty much central to the plot, but it’s handled incredibly poorly. We see no stance taken on issues surrounding mental health except for those of our villains and, whilst I don’t think Lidster himself believes that “being depressed is selfish because our ancestors had to fight in wars”, he never really presents a counter argument so all we’re left with is a ridiculously harmful and ignorant viewpoint that really just rubs me the wrong way. And it’s here where Lidster fails in character writing because there’s no point to any of this focus on manic depression as none of our characters have really grown at the end, they just seem to be how they were at the start with Liam and Caitriona still in a weird, toxic friendship where they each ignore their own problems by helping the other with theirs. I think it’s just a well-meaning allegory that was poorly executed (or at least I hope it is) but the way it’s written feels somewhat scummy. As for the plot itself, it’s just pretty badly written. It has one too many plot holes for me, there’s a part three twist where the Doctor’s old friend, Gustavo, turns out to be working with Gabriel and Jude, but that whole subplot is dropped five minutes later. Why Gabriel’s music can hypnotise and even kill people isn’t ever really explained besides “his music’s really good” and the use of PCP (though I think it’s funny that the “angel dust” Gabriel uses to help people ascend was fully just the drug angel dust, no subtlety whatsoever). The whole thing feels underbaked and is really a B-tier Doctor Who episode with nothing wholly special or unique about it, which is a shame because there were some good ideas knocking around in here, Lidster was just clearly having an off day.

The Rapture is a really poor debut for one of my favourite audio writers. The 17 blistering tracks advertised on the front cover make for a dizzying sensory experience with some absolutely wonderful character work thrown in, but it all feels surface level. Kind of like a rave in that respect, so maybe this whole thing is genius and I’m just missing the point. But the mishandling of mental health and a somewhat uninspired story make The Rapture overall a disappointment. There are things to admire here, but nothing that makes the story worth it.

5/10

Pros:

+ The material with Ace and Liam works surprisingly well and is genuinely quite sweet

+ The rave-fuelled soundtrack is incredibly fun

+ Really interesting editing style that makes for some very fun sequences

Cons:

- Gabriel and Jude make for underwhelming antagonists

- Littered with some pretty bad performances

- Has some weird, shaky morals surrounding mental health and depression

- Messy plot that feels very underdeveloped

06.08.2022

I enjoyed it immensely. Though the story loses itself in a few places, the setting makes up for it. I love DW at the rave party. Ace's brother arc is mirroring the villains which is always nice.
I have a problem with usual clichés made a little too cartoony here, but it's not enough to give it anything lower than 3/5.

MR 036: The Rapture

Oh we're getting religious in here now are we? Between that and hearing everyone call Ace "McShane" or "Dorothy" this was a really odd one, but a good one.

Ace is depressed after seeing David Tennant split in two in the TARDIS, understandably so, and insists that everyone call her McShane. And the Doctor wants to take her on a holiday. Enter the Rapture dance club, run by two literal angels where people go to have a religious experience.

Relating dance clubs to religion is interesting. You can get the same feeling from everyone moving and dancing to the music as you can from religious music in a church. Which definitely makes sense.

The club's angels play music that literally puts everyone into a trance so that they don't know what's happening.

The second episode is the best part I think. The entire episode bounces back and forth between three conversations, not cutting between them. One character ends off on a line that another character is saying in their conversation. It's well written, edited, and acted. Ace finds out that she has a long lost brother separated as a toddler. One of the angel DJs gives a drug to someone suffering from bi polar. And the Doctor works out what's happening with an old friend of his.

And can we stop to take a moment and say how bizarre it is that the Doctor has a friend he made fighting in the Spanish civil war? I thought that was changing Earth history. I thought you hated doing that. We learned that in Colditz. Yet for some reason you deemed it acceptable to fight in the Spanish Civil War just as you deemed it acceptable to undo the Nazi timeline in Colditz. Very hypocritical.

That's not important to this story. It's just odd, I'm not used to the Doctor outright fighting fascists on Earth, he always makes some lame excuse not to. Like in Fearmonger.

We find out that the angel DJs are refugees from a war where their peaceful people were attacked. One of them got PTSD from fighting and ended up having his mind scrambled and his brother has somehow convinced him that they're actual, real angels. They plan to conscript all the people in the club with their trance music to fight in their war. Which is a pretty wild plan.

Only the plan goes awry when the brother who genuinely believes he's an angel dies along with the Doctor's friend, who initially sponsored this, but wasn't keen on the conscription part.

There's some arguments here that without a grand enemy to fight or something greater to belong to or believe in, people just slip into depression and "battling themselves" as the Doctor's friend and the one angel argue. Which definitely is slipping into fascist territory, ironically considering they've both fought fascists. That's the exact rhetoric that fascists use to lure people in: the need to belong to something greater than oneself alone.

As revenge, the other angel seeks to take revenge for his brother's death by killing everyone. Which is, uh, a choice. But the Doctor stops him by talking him down and relating his brother relationship with Ace and her long lost brother.

There's definitely some really good character work for Ace here as she struggles to cope with the idea of a long lost brother and a long lost father who left a long time ago. Ace has a tendency to lash out when things get too real for her and she does it here. She yells at him and runs away. It's definitely reminiscent of Fenric when she realizes that the baby she's protecting is her mom and how upset that makes her feel. They do end on good terms with Ace promising to return. She thought about leaving, but she can't. Understandably so.

Overall it's pretty ok. A story with a lot of pathos, especially with sibling relationships. I liked a lot of the editing here as well as the music. They made a cute dance music intro for this story only and it's a nice change of pace.