An honestly engaging story about the environment and a warning about power hungry people who will even commit genocide to reach their goals.

turns out the warriors and the mutants are two parts in the cycle of some real f**ked up periodic cicadas. also the doctor is back in his purple lined cape and crimson velvet jacket. it's quite a look

This is a serial that by all accounts, it has a lot of what I love about Doctor Who and this era in particular.  Yet, The Mutants is one of those serials with a lot of elements that just don’t click.  It’s a serial with a handful of supporting cast performances that just do not work, Rick James being generally the worst (his delivery is almost entirely stilted).  The cast generally feels almost entirely miscast: Paul Whitson-Jones as the Marshal is the one supporting cast member that I think works well, Garrick Hagen is trying but the material for his character Ky really does dry up in the back half of the serial, and both George Pravda and John Hollis are competing with each other for most ridiculous accent (Pravda wins).

Bob Baker and Dave Martin also genuinely struggle, perhaps the most, with the pacing of a six part serial.  The Mutants has enough material for six but the script struggles with getting from plot point to plot point.  Structuring the inciting incident of the Doctor having to deliver a message for the Time Lords always keeps him as an outsider even though he supports the people of Solos in overcoming their oppressive, apartheid overlords.  Doing active commentary on South Africa during apartheid is also bold and actually quite good for what it’s doing, it’s just keeping the Doctor in the story naturally that doesn’t work (pulling the trick from Colony in Space and The Curse of Peladon would have worked much better).  The costumes of the story are brilliant, especially the futuristic designs, same with the general sets and the Mutants themselves.  Christopher Barry as a director also excels at the psychedelic sequences and making the sets feel both futuristic and the location feel like an alien planet.  I’d like this a lot more if there were just some minor changes to the structure and keeping the Doctor not feel like an observer who could easily leave whenever he wanted to.

I actually really liked this one! A very cohesive plot for a six-episode serial, with some biting political commentary.

A+.

Another one where the time lords send the doctor on a mission. Apart from Peladon, this doctor on another planet aren't very good stories so far. Just like Colony, this one is a bit boring but has a few ok scenes.

Man, this one hard to get through. A couple good ideas, like the metamorphosis being supposed to happen and the whole colonialism+Apartheid analogy, but God the characters were terrible and the science (particle inversion?) was noticeably wonky, too silly even by DW standards. I think this story would work better as a tighter 4-parter rather than the 6-parter it is. I lost count on how many times they go from the planet surface to the Skybase and back again. The main villain, the Marshal, was just so over the top evil and despicable his motives weren't even interesting, and his communicator stick thingy was dumb. This is the first Pertwee story that didn't click with me, which is a shame.

“They are monsters, they don’t deserve to live!”

Sadly, it’s possibly one of the worst, if not the worst of the Pertwee era. A story with some great ideas, and some really great direction and visuals but it’s just so boring and drab. Six repetitive episodes that don’t particularly say it do much, with rather boring characters other than the Marshall, who is a fun, albeit scenery chewing villain.

The visuals are decent however. Some great direction, and really great use of lighting, especially in the caves and some fun use of the space ship. The costumes for the mutants themselves is decent too, even if they feel underutilised overall.

It’s sadly just boring, far too long, with a lack of material to really manage to capture any level of intrigue over six episodes.

THAT WAS FUCKING ASS NUMBING

A bit on the slow side -- it definitely could've been a quite pacy four-parter -- but it's a genuinely enjoyable story that takes a hard environmentalist and anti-colonial stance. Pertwee and Manning are as delightful a duo as ever, and the guest cast by and large deliver very compelling performances as well. There are some really nice moments in this one; it's just a shame that it plods so much along the way.

I very much enjoyed Bob Baker and Dave Martin's The Claws of Axos. For their second outing we can see several significant social issues being explored. Solos has a three tier class system. Native Solonians are ruled by Earth "Overlords" who have controlled Solos for 500 years, there is also a persecuted underclass of Solonians who have become infected (seemingly by the destroyed environment) and are mutating into "mutts" or "mutants".

The Doctor and Jo have been sent to Solos to deliver a sphere that will only open for one person. They step into a fractured world where the old guard seem to be in their last throws of their reign. Solos is no longer of interest to the Earth Empire, in part because the environment has been wrecked by the Overlords. It is of course tragic that the Solonians were to be set free by The Administrator before being killed by the rebel Kai, a character which the audience should almost certainly side with. Kai is of course the individual who the sphere was meant for.

Jo now well and truly feels like the quintessential companion. She demands they head towards danger despite The Doctor's protests to protect her. Although why The Doctor continues to demand she stay away from danger after the adventures they have shared is beyond me!

Firestorms and the eerie, mysterious caves show off more of Baker and Martin's trademark trippy visuals. It is great seeing The Doctor struggling as the frame rate gets slower and the CSO becomes beautiful and captivating. The Doctor is brave in an interesting way here. I prefer watching the Third Doctor travel into this kind of danger rather than driving around in cars making pretentious quips. I am in love with Pertwee here. He is our first true hero Doctor, watching him carry the examiner from Earth over his shoulders is a game changer in what we expect from the character.

It is sad seeing Kai surrounded by mutants attacking him who he still refers to as "his people", it is of great credit to this character. I love that we are never sure which characters are on which sides. Solonians against Solonians, Overlords against Overlords. We are left to judge characters on their individual merits and gain a deeper understanding over why divisions exist in social groups, The Mutants is not shying away from being complex. At first I didn't think it quite worked that the Marshal's men betrayed him so easily, but once I witnessed the two of them be betrayed by him themselves it becomes obvious why this man has so few loyal followers.

A hole gets shot in the side of the spaceship, our heroes are being sucked out into space. This is a fantastic cliff hanger (the best one in a very, very long time). The reveal that the mutations are not unnatural, instead the next stage of a 500 year Solonian life-cycle is also among the most ingenious plot twists in the show so far.

The ending of The Mutants is of course complete nonsense. This story has been an allegory for race relations, apartheids and colonisation. So what are we meant to make of the benevolent super-race that the mutants transform into? It feels like The Mutants jumps the shark and loses touch with the social messages it begins with. Maybe the point is "don't colonise other races, or one day they will develop and overthrow you". Or maybe "don't colonise other races, this is will allow them to develop at a faster rate". Neither of these seem satisfying. Or maybe its just the last episode of a Doctor Who story and we're simply supposed to enjoy the ride.

I very much like this duo's writing style and I'm looking forward to their third outing; but this one's ending wasn't spot on for me.

The Mutants reminds me a lot of Colony in Space. Both are very dry, boring stories that should be more exciting as we have the Third Doctor finally able to leave Earth. This serial just doesn't work for me, between the lame-looking sets and costumes and the even goofier story, I just did not get much out of these episodes. Even the Doctor and Jo just don't get any of their usual fun character moments here. It's just a sweaty, messy chapter in Doctor Who history I'd rather not revisit any time soon.

The Mutants has it all: a surpringly well-done anti-colonial and anti-racist story for 70s Doctor Who, good pacing for a 6-parter, and perhaps most importantly the Third Doctor in shirtsleeves