“What a waste. What a terrible waste.”

La série n’a jamais été aussi éprouvante. 

Il y a en effet plein de gens qui meurent aussitôt qu’on les rencontre. Et surtout ce Docteur n'a jamais été aussi seul, et pourtant forcé de courir partout. 

Mais c’est donc tout son univers qui s’effondre dans une bataille absolument atroce, et si la série est carrément vidée de sa joie, elle est surtout vidée de toute son humanité.

En fait, c'est un rare moment de doute pour Doctor Who.  Son monde est terrifiant, et frappé par des guerres atroces et des monstres sanguinaires. Mais il n’est plus capable de faire rêver. 

Et alors que tout un monde est en train de mourir, qu’est-ce qui pourra donc vraiment naître de ses cendres ?  

"I'm afraid, my friends, the Daleks have won."

Taken me a few days to get through this twelve part epic, most of which sadly no longer exists. It certainly feels like the largest scale story up to this point. It can get a little bit like The Chase, with a couple of the middle episodes totally meandering and meaningless to the rest of the plot. But overall it's a big epic, with a lot of great moments.

William Hartnell and Peter Purves are both great throughout, especially Hartnell. Some of the later episodes giving this Doctor some of his best moments, standing up against the Daleks. Were also treated to new companions who come and go. A highlight being Nicholas Courtney for the first few episodes, it's pretty obvious why they bring back his charisma in later years as a main stay. Both Adrienne Hill and Jean Marsh are nice additions but sadly we don't spend long enough with them. Their time with the Doctor too fleeting.

The Daleks themselves are well utilised, feeling more threatening and less comedic than their last appearance. Theres a real sense of danger and threat to them, whenever they are on screen. Mavic Chen is also a great villain. He's menacing and formidable, and a brilliant performance from Kevin Stoney, it's a shame that more of this performance isn't captured on the existing episodes.

A fun, if a little long and meandering, epic. I wish more of the story was available to watch properly, but as it stands it's entertaining and grand in scale. It could have easily worked as Hartnell's swangsong.

Well, here we are, The Daleks' Master Plan, one of the most legendary Dalek stories, hell, to us hardcores, one of the most legendary Doctor Who stories, and given that hype, I gotta say, I'm a bit disappointed.
Now, the story is still good, well deserving of an 8, but it generally just feels a bit unambitious, just your run-of-the-mill Dalek story, without much to make it stand out, other than the immense length... and the yellowface.

The plot is basically; The Daleks have assembled powerful people from all around the galaxy (for no apparent reason) and one guy from Earth that has something that enables them to control/destroy/fast-forward time, The Doctor steals it, they play hot potato and then the machine gets destroyed.
Where it really wins back points for me is the fact that it's able to be coherent, fun and engaging for 12 straight parts, that's almost 5 hours! How many stories do you know that can keep your attention without complaint for 5 straight hours? That takes some doing, hats off to Terry Nation and Dennis Spooner, that's a damn achievement.

More points come from the good performances, The Doctor is good, Steven and Sara are great, and much as I hate to admit it, the walking hate crime puts in a good performance as well.
The silly little break in the middle in the form of The Feast of Steven really works for me as just that, and of course the "...and Incidentally, a merry Christmas to all of you at home!" is one of the most legendary moments in Classic Who.
My favourite part, however, is the final part and how it completely refuses to pull its punches, killing off Sara in a very affecting scene and seriously injuring The Doctor, leading to one of William Hartnell's best performances (he was always the best at playing gruff) as he yells for Steven to get back to the TARDIS, the only black mark on that amazing scene is how quickly The Doctor goes back to his amused little laugh, a little callous in the face of the death of a person he liked.

So, really, the reason that I was disappointed was expectations, the story is good, quite good even, it just doesn't hold a candle to something as awe-inspiring as Genesis of The Daleks or The Dalek Invasion of Earth. It is quite good, it simply fails to be great.

8/10

The Daleks Master Plan: 9.4 - What a masterpiece. This story was absolutely epic. The first four episodes were great and Bret was a great semi companion. Katarina was a bit of an underwhelming companion however and her death was very anticlimactic. The introduction of Sara however was great and her devotion to Mavic Chen, and the eventual murder of her brother, was very dark. Sara was overall a fantastic character through the story and her death was sad. The Feast of Steven was a very weird episode but I actually ended up enjoying it. I also liked the Daleks in this serial and think that they still hold a threat even with their numerous appearances so far. Steven was another part of the serial that was very strong in my opinion. Mavic Chen was also a fantastic villain and we all knew of his inevitable downfall as no one can truly ally with the daleks.

I’m splitting dmp up into 3 stories it works with my mind knowing theres stories set after feast of steven its my review im doing it so shush Anyway katarina f**king DIED WTF best girl only has 1 surviving episode I can’t then then intro another companion bret and he f**king dies And then we have Sara I BELIEVE IN JEAN MARSH SUPREMACY Anyway great script GREAT CAST I’m loving this story love where it’s going I’m excited to do the big finish stuff inbetween

feast of steven - What a fun campy romp it’s not amazing but it does the job for a Christmas doctor who story

dmp 8-12 - What an amazing end the DMP era of the show has an amazing vibe like you feel like it’s one whole series in itself

The Daleks’ Master Plan (DMP) is a lot.

I think that’s fair to say. It is the longest story in all of Doctor Who at more than 4 hours total, but it’s more than just length that makes this story stand out. It’s by far the largest in scale the show has ever gone. And with at least 7 audio adventures in the middle of it, it’s legacy only continues to grow. On top of that, it also feels like a mission statement for the rest of the season with a change in tone, but time will tell if that’s really the case.

The story starts straight after the Myth Makers, with new companion Katarina and Steven being poisoned by an arrow. The Doctor is trying to land the Tardis in a safe location and find Steven the help he needs. Sadly, he instead lands on the planet Kembel, which we have already seen in “Mission to the Unknown”. The Daleks are using the planet as a base to prepare for a massive attack on the solar system. They plan to use a mysterious weapon known as the “Time Destructor”. They’ve also allied themselves with several powerful figures, most notably Mavic Chen, Guardian of the Solar System.

Luckily for the party, the Time Destructor is not yet complete. It lacks 1 crucial element: a Terranium core, which the party has managed to get their hands on. This leads to a chase across different planets, time zones, the works.

And you might have noticed, that this bears a striking resemblance to “The Chase” the previous Dalek TV episode. You’d not be entirely wrong. What sets DMP apart, however, is the tone. Where the Chase was fun sci-fi shenanigans, DMP goes for a more serious story. Gone are the days of Daleks vs Dracula. This tries to put the fear back into the Daleks.

And I’d argue that worked. This story is remembered for its dark elements, like the deaths of several potential companions and the entire last episode. Those moments hit hard and are done wonderfully. They’re given the right amount of reflection from the main cast. Never taken for granted. It also leads to some possible future directions for the show, more on that later.

But while there is some clear ambition, it isn’t all sunshine and roses (or, considering the dark material, moonlight and lilies?). While the idea of “The Chase 2” with double the episodes sounds fun, at a certain point it maybe becomes too much. The setpieces overtake the overall narrative and we lose cohesion. We have some good initial setup, but what happens after that setup is basically a roll of the dice. We are in Egypt! Or a planet of invisible monsters! Or a prison planet! Or a volcano! It’s unbridled adventure where anything can happen, and while that’s exciting, I wish it all connected a little more.

It, of course, doesn’t help that most of the story is missing. Only 3 of the original 12 episodes are currently available. It also has no animated version. With all these locations, some visual excitement is part of the experience. But we don’t have that visual part, so some of the excitement is gone.

So how do we deal with that giant hole? Well, we do have 1 twinkle of hope. Youtuber Josh Snares has taken it upon himself to animate most of this story himself, using 3d models and photo stills to turn it into a really solid reconstruction. Consider it a “creative slideshow”, if you will. It’s probably the best way to experience the story, so I recommend you check it out.

But despite these fan efforts, the visuals we currently have are still very limited. That automatically puts the narrative and characterization under some higher scrutiny. If you don’t have visuals to look at, the other aspects of the story become more noticeable.

And those other aspects are… iffy. Like I mentioned, it suffers from a lack of overall narrative. For example, the central theme is stopping the creation of the time destructor, but what does a time destructor actually do? Sure, it has an intimidating name, but the story never takes a break to tell us why this is actually a weapon worth stopping.

The same happens to characters. We see Sara Kingdom shooting her brother on sight. Not a moment is spared. Meet him. Shoot him. Speaking 2 sentences with each other would have prevented this whole thing. Yet almost immediately afterwards, we are supposed to feel sorry for her and she becomes a companion for a bit. It’s incredibly erratic.

And we do get a glimpse of what the story could be like if it paced itself a little better. In episode 1, the story feels much more natural. The Doctor explores the dangerous new planet alone, while Katarina meets Bret and tries to save Steven from his poisoning. It’s much slower. Allowing us to meet both Bret and Katarina. Katarina is shown as out of her depth and not very proactive. She is a bit of an onlooker. She watches how others resolve the plot. It’s not like she’s pushed to the sideline. She just prefers to watch and learn. She’s is consciously written as a more passive character. Meanwhile Bret is shown as threatening at first, but he also cures Steven’s poison, showing the good guy underneath and allowing that initial bond of trust.

But these kinds of moments get lost in the later scramble. Sara has the least amount of characterization out of the 3 newcomers, because when she enters the story, we’re already planet hopping without standing still. I would’ve gladly given up 1 among the dozens of locations in this story, if it meant we got a bit more character. Instead, we’re just too busy.

And it’s interesting how “The Chase” didn’t have similar problems, because it just had a really strong main cast. Ian, Barbara and the Doctor were established 2 seasons ago, while Vicki had an extremely solid entrance in the second season. Yet even then, when Steven was introduced. We took a lot of time and really made it count. I can still remember his reaction when Barbara first said his name. The first time he heard it in 2 years and it showed. DMP doesn’t have those same luxuries. We know the Doctor and Steven well enough, but Katarina, Bret and Sara mostly pass us by. Our base characterization is not as solid as it was then, so our investment is lower.

But even with that lower investment, I think there are plenty of moments that still land. Like I mentioned earlier, the tone of this story is a massive shift from the previous season. Doctor Who got darker. I can’t put it better than Samuel Davis: The only icon of childlike innocence is ejected out of an airlock. It’s a brutal mission statement. And that brutality carries on in loads of places. This story has a massive kill count of main characters, which makes every mention of the words “exterminate” or “kill” hit that much harder.

And that’s not even mentioning the last episode, where the story hits its peak. In those last 20 minutes, the time destructor turns on. While late, we now find out why this is a weapon worth destroying. It turns the entire jungle planet into a desert wasteland. Everything decays before our eyes. Sadly, this includes Sara, who slowly turns old and grey, before later turning to dust. It is brutal and genuinely disturbing. Seeing Sara’s decayed skeleton blow away in the wind while the doctor is unconscious and half-buried in the sand is a sharp contrast from the doctor happily skipping around on new planets last season. A real mission statement. Let’s hope it gets found one day, because this is something that can’t be replaced.

It also leads to an ending which leaves so much room for further character exploration. We’re in a wasteland with nothing left standing. It’s all dust except Steven, the Doctor and the Tardis. Nothing but decay. So the doctor looks around, put his fingers on his lapels like we’ve seen him do so many times, and chuckles. He congratulates himself on a job well done. Another plan stopped. He only remembers the bad side when Steven counts up all the names of people they’ve lost along the way.

It's genuinely a bit shocking of first watch. And might even feel out of character. Our hero has destroyed a world and then chuckled to himself. But on lookback. It makes sense. This goes back to season 1. This is the same man who laughed at danger and forced his companions into the Dalek city so he could feed his own curiosity. This is the same man who in a comedic moment invented the great fire of Rome. The same man who left behind a group of women on a planet that was falling apart. He’s a complex character with a simple world view. This view has been tested a lot since then, and he has learned kindness and empathy, but will those messages stick when the people that taught him that are long gone? Can he still do “the right thing” on his own?

It's an impasse in his development. He is a better man than he was before, but that doesn’t make him perfect. It’s interesting to put some pressure on that and I wonder if anything will come from it. A really interesting note to end the story on.

And that’s how the Daleks’ Master Plan ends. It’s a long saga with many characters, locations and iconic moments. And just to top it off, it also has a really interesting tonal shift that shows great promise for the future. Is it perfect? Absolutely not. It’s a very visual affair that no longer has it’s visuals, it’s so busy throwing stuff at the wall that it forgets to reinforce what actually sticks and it’s main plot is often forgotten in between. But the end product is still really fun, creative and memorable. Take your time with it, sprinkle some audio’s in between and you’re guaranteed a good time.

Bonus: The Feast of Steven:

This one is odd. Officially part of the Daleks’ master plan, but such an odd one out. That’s why it gets its own discussion.

First of all, like most of DMP, this story does not actually exit anymore. It also hasn’t been remade like the other parts. Reason being it really isn’t all that relevant to the other episodes. However, youtuber DocMagister has made an animated version, which is the definitive way of experiencing this story.

Te story is basically a random series of events with the Doctor, Steven and Sara. There’s no real throughline. It’s just some sightseeing. We enter a police station and a movie set, with some adequate humor in between.

Part of this humoristic venture seems to be a lot of random screaming and yelling over each other. Presenting business as comedy. Can’t say my ears love that.

This episode is remembered for 2 reasons.  First of all, this is a Christmas special, ending with the Doctor talking to the Christmas and wishing “a merry Christmas to all of you at home”. A sentence burned into the heart of many a who fan, I’m sure.

The other reason this is remembered is a bit more notorious. This is the story where the doctor goes “It’s a madhouse! It’s all full of Arabs”. Which is a bit racist.

This story is probably not the best place to talk extensively about racism in Doctor Who, but this sentence is the one people always point to as the biggest example. I’ll just throw in that, on average, I’ve not experienced the first Doctor as a racist. Granted, I wasn’t actively paying attention to racist remarks. And I won’t deny that there are clear 60s sensibilities at times. But I wonder if I’ve missed something obvious. Are there really that many moments besides this one hidden in a terrible off-shoot Christmas special? I wonder. Once again, not denying them, but I’m curious what I’m missing.

But yeah, except 2 snippets, there really isn’t much this episode has going for it. In fact, it’s quite bad as a whole. An indulgence of the time. Worth watching? Nah. Feel free to miss it. We now have Christmas specials that actually play with the Doctor Who premise, instead of a runaround that happens to have the Doctor in it.

Conclusively, I suppose there’s only one thing left to say: A Merry Christmas to all of you at home 😊

Shockingly watchable for a 12-part Hartnell story where 9/12 episodes are missing. The whole thing does get a little repetitive and meandery at times and I'm not the biggest fan of the Daleks, but it jumps around enough in setting to keep the whole thing going, and the climax in the final episode absolutely pays off. If I could bring back one single missing episode of Classic Who, it might just be episode 12 of this.