Fun Fun Fun Fun Fun Fun Fun… I think this episode is a ton of fun.

The plot such as it is involves the Doctor noticing some sci-fi anomalies surrounding a hospital, so checks himself in. Here he meets trainee doctor Martha Jones, just in time for the hospital to be transported onto the moon. This is due to the Judoon, some interplanetary police for hire, who are searching for a criminal in the hospital, but as they have no jurisdiction on Earth, had to transport the hospital onto neutral territory, the moon in this case. The hospital is in a forcefield, so has its own atmosphere; however there is a finite amount of air, so the oxygen is running out. The Judoon search for an alien, which is a problem for our alien hero. This becomes more of an issue because the villain is a Plasmavore, who drink the blood of their victims. Once they drink the blood of their victims, they take on their genetic properties, allowing the Plasmavore to pass as human. The Doctor has to not only trick the Plasmavore into getting captures by the Judoon before the oxygen runs out in the hospital. He also has to stop an energy blast going off, hastily made from an MRI machine, that will not only kill everyone on the moon, but also half the population of the Earth.

This episode zips along at a nice, breezy pace. The dialogue is fun, but never undercuts the multiple threats in play here. The oxygen running out in the hospital means there is a ticking clock to events, increasing the sense of tension and urgency within the episode.

Anne Reid as the Plasmavore is having fun and makes for an interesting villain. Her chemistry and banter with the Doctor is a delight too.

The Judoon are both a fun design and a fun secondary antagonist for the episode. They aren’t villains; they’re just idiotic thugs with police powers, who just single-mindedly follow their protocols. This means they keep getting in the way, and because they’re looking for an alien they become a force for the Doctor to constantly need to avoid.

As good as all these elements are, the main draw of this episode is Martha Jones. I really like Martha in this episode. She’s instantly likeable, smart & perceptive. She’s willing to take risks, and proves herself a worthy sidekick for the Doctor here. I also like that she has her own life going on. She has a messy but relatable family dynamic. She has aspirations, wanting to become a doctor herself. I personally think that Martha gets the best introductory episode out of the 3 main RTD era companions, and she’s setup so well for the rest of the series.

This isn’t an all-time classic by any stretch. But as a light, enjoyable episode of television to ease you back into a new series, and as an introduction for a new companion, it’s really frickin’ good. Also did I mention that it’s fun.

Thworping through time and space, one adventure at a time!

"SMITH AND JONES – A LUNAR LAUNCH FOR MARTHA JONES"

Series 3 of Doctor Who kicks off with Smith and Jones, a pacey, inventive, and often downright silly adventure that introduces Freema Agyeman’s Martha Jones in classic RTD fashion—a grounded family, a familiar modern setting, and then a sudden jump to the absolutely absurd. Like Rose and New Earth before it, the series opener is less about plot complexity and more about character establishment. And in that regard, this story delivers.

Martha’s introduction is instantly charming: a confident, capable medical student caught in the middle of family drama and professional duty. Freema Agyeman nails her first appearance, portraying Martha as clever, calm under pressure, and independent—an ideal foil to the now grieving, slightly manic Tenth Doctor. Her scientific background sets her apart from Rose, and the way the Doctor essentially tests her throughout the story ("you're clever, that means you’re useful") establishes her as a competent companion from the off.

There’s also a very Davies-esque efficiency in how the Doctor is reintroduced to the audience. New viewers get all the essentials—the two hearts, the blue police box, the Time Lord title—doled out naturally throughout the story without slowing the pace. The moment the Doctor first appears in the street, nonchalantly removes his tie, says “Like so, see?” and walks off is wonderfully mad, teasing both Martha and the audience with a mystery that only makes sense much later.

JUDOON ON THE MOON

The high-concept idea—an entire hospital yoinked to the Moon—is pure popcorn Doctor Who. The effects hold up reasonably well, with shots of the lunar surface and the stomping Judoon ships providing solid spectacle. The green screen shows through a bit, but the visual scope is ambitious for early Revival-era Who, and the design of the Judoon, with their heavy armour and rhino heads, remains one of the show’s more memorable creations.

The Judoon, introduced as a galactic police force-for-hire, are simultaneously menacing and amusing. Their logic-first approach to justice (“non-hu-man!”) and trademark guttural language ("Sko! Blo! Mo!") have cemented their place in the Who iconography, despite being hilariously bad at aiming. They’re like militarised, bureaucratic stormtroopers with space rhinos for heads.

BLOOD AND CHAOS

The plot is straightforward, but it hangs on Anne Reid’s delightfully evil Plasmavore, a killer alien hiding among humans by drinking blood with a straw—Doctor Who never quite loses its fondness for the silly macabre. Reid, a veteran of both Classic (The Curse of Fenric) and New Who, sinks her teeth into the role (literally) and sells the character’s deception and cruelty with relish.

Direction by Charles Palmer maintains a snappy rhythm, especially during the middle stretch where chaos reigns in the hospital halls. Judoon marching, patients panicking, and the Doctor frantically racing to solve the mystery—it's pure RTD-era bedlam. The extras do commendable work selling the panic.

However, that chaos comes with a downside. The plot does become something of a runaround halfway through, with Martha and the Doctor zipping from room to corridor, and the secondary threat of oxygen depletion is largely ignored until the final act. There's a ticking clock, but the script forgets to wind it.

KISSES, CLOWNING, AND CHARACTER

The biggest misstep is the Doctor’s kiss. Used here to transfer genetic data to Martha (sci-fi nonsense, but sure), it unintentionally kickstarts her unrequited crush subplot for the season. It’s a bit of a whiplash moment—he barely knows her, and there’s no chemistry yet to justify it beyond a plot device. Worse, it undermines the more organic development of Martha’s admiration for the Doctor across the episode.

That said, Tennant is firing on all cylinders. His post-Rose Doctor has a new edge—still bouncing with energy and quips, but there's an underlying grief that colours his performance, especially when he briefly mentions Rose. The scene where he pretends to be a dim human under interrogation is a fun highlight, as is his willingness to risk himself by allowing the Plasmavore to suck his blood, knowing it’ll expose her.

Less convincing is the "expel all radiation via silly dance" sequence. Tennant just about sells it, but it's one of those tonal wobbles that lands somewhere between goofy charm and embarrassing filler.

A SOLID LAUNCHPAD

Smith and Jones is a soft reboot that mostly succeeds. It introduces a new companion with flair, gives Tennant space to shift gears post-Rose, and peppers in just enough spectacle to be memorable. The Judoon are fun, the Plasmavore is gruesomely entertaining, and the Moon-bound hospital is a great setpiece, even if the story itself doesn’t do much beyond the introduction of new toys.

The emotional core is still there, and it’s in the small things—Martha’s decision to help rather than panic, the Doctor grieving through chaos, and a lovely final moment where she negotiates a trip in the TARDIS on her terms. That’s the real win.

📝THE BOTTOM LINE:

An entertaining and energetic opener that introduces Martha Jones with confidence and flair, Smith and Jones is a slightly wobbly but fun blend of sci-fi spectacle and character reintroduction. Not quite a classic, but a solid new start. 8/10

A second underrated story in a row, and proof that even the era of the show I am most familiar with still holds surprises. Rhino headed aliens are a stroke of genius, you can see how deft RTD is at creating immediately accessible and relatable enemies for the general public. But crucially they are not the ultimate bad guys - they are heavy handed bureaucrats subjecting a hospital to mistreatment in the name of hunting down a lady who sucks blood through a straw. It’s light and frivolous, as we’ve come to expect with these opening stories - but it’s very much got a solid plot. It holds up significantly better than the series 2 opener.

Martha Jones is the real stars of this show though. Freema Agyemen is a gentle delight. Not going to thwack you round the face with her performance like Tate or even Piper, but plays a more introverted, quiet confidence. An open eyed and excited new look on the universe. I like that she has a serious profession and that she is intelligent and highly qualified. Her chemistry with The Doctor, especially when he takes his tie off at the beginning and end of the show is wonderful.

Shout out to the family arguments as well - why is Russell so good at writing those? The pathetic dad with his ridiculous girlfriend “this is me, putting my foot down!” It gives Martha a sense of reality around her.

I've always had a lot of love for Smith and Jones, even if it isn't everyone's favourite episode. I think it is such a wonderful and clean entry point for the series.

It feels like an episode full of joy. Our characters might be in danger but the Judoon represent a fun threat more than a spooky one. The old lady is pretty brutal with her special straw but it all is played largely for laughs. David Tennant gets a lot of great comedy bits, and though one's mileage may vary in that regard, it's still just a solid introduction to Martha and a pretty important episode as an introduction for the Judoon (who I've always had a special place in my heart for).

All told it is pretty solid. Great set-up and pay-off with the tie to frame and subtly introduce a bit of time travel in a story otherwise focused on some fun with the Judoon on the moon. It's silly but the hospital setting and scenario gave the episode a lot of structure. On the whole, I think it all worked out quite well.

New Who Review #29

Smith & Jones

This episode was fun. I enjoyed the setting of this episode. The Moon was a great location not yet explored in new who. Some parts of this episode were gorgeous. The Judoon were a funny Race and I'm glad they returned in series 12. Martha is a companion I've never really clicked with but Freema Agyeman really plays her well. Mrs Finnegan was a shock villain and the way she drains people's blood was dark. Overall this episode gets a 8/10