Skip to content

Dalek Universe 1 • Episode 2

The Wrong Woman

4.15/ 5 78 votes

Reviews and links from the Community

Review of The Wrong Woman by The9thCyberLegion

Gorgeous cover art and gorgeous story, I am however beginning to think that Clara wasn't the only one who jumped down the Doctor's timeline. The Impossible Gatiss, series 7C!!!

Review last edited on 15-09-24

Review of The Wrong Woman by WhoPotterVian

 I'm impressed with how long the story commits to the idea that the Tenth Doctor has regenerated into a Gemma Whelan incarnation. Obviously, this isn't the case, as we got Matt Smith after David Tennant on TV, but the story makes you wonder for a while whether this is somehow a legitimate incarnation.

The reveal is teased well throughout, with the Tenth Doctor breaking through to Anya Kingdom from the future. When the twist comes that Gemma Whelan is actually the Monk, it feels extremely satisfying, because of the hints in the first two parts of Dalek Universe which suddenly make sense when her identity is confirmed. Gemma Whelan makes for an excellent Monk, and bounces off David Tennant extremely well.

The latter half of the story, with time collapsing on itself, reminded me a lot of The Wedding Of River Song. It has the same concept of elements from past time periods emerging into a future time, with prehistoric animals and cavemen roaming the streets. In my view, it handles it better than The Wedding Of River Song, as it feels much more coherent, and less of an unruly mess.

Review last edited on 4-09-24

Community Ratings


TARDIS Guide

Votes: 78
Average rating: 4.15 / 5

The Time Scales

Votes: 73
Average rating: 4.25 / 5


(Updates coming soon:)

Add the last X members who rated it here

Add number of Favs, and who they are, here

Ratings are from TARDIS Guide members only.