Skip to content

Short Trips

The People’s Temple

3.51/ 5 16 votes*

Reviews and links from the Community

Review of The People’s Temple by deltaandthebannermen

The People’s Temple is a short story by Paul Leonard which was originally published in BBC Books Short Trips anthology. It was subsequently read by Paul McGann as one of the three stories on BBC Audio’s Earth and Beyond collection which featured the only original material performed by McGann in the wake of the TV Movie – at least until Big Finish came along.

The People’s Temple tells of the Doctor and Sam Jones (a companion from the full length novels published at the time) visiting Stonehenge during its construction. The plot revolves around Sam attempting a ‘Barbara in the Aztecs’ by stopping a sacrifice which ultimately leads to her realising that she cannot affect the behaviour of a race of people as different to her as aliens from another world.

We meet members of the tribe, in particular Bear and Deer who we meet briefly as children before fast-forwarding to their time as adults and the Doctor and Sam’s arrival. Bear Cub is now Great Bear, the ‘physical’ leader of the tribe, whereas Young Deer is the Deer Man, seemingly the ‘religious’ leader of the tribe. Sam saves a young boy, already perceived as a man by the tribe’s culture, from sacrifice.

The setting of Stonehenge is sketchily presented with reference to round huts and wooden and earth defences, as well as, obviously, the stones themselves (one of which crushes a poor unfortunate girl).

Overall, The People’s Temple is a little slow and uneventful. The slightly dreary setting is reflected in slightly dreary characters and a slightly dreary plot. The possibility for an interesting dichotomy in the two sides of the tribe represented by Bear and Deer is not really explored and Sam’s contact with Doran, the young sacrificial victim, has some potentially interesting material when he first experiences the TARDIS, but ultimately comes down to Sam realising that, try as she might, she cannot impose her values and culture on to a human who has been brought up in a totally alien culture to hers.

I’ve only listened to The People’s Temple about twice since buying the cassette in the late 90s and, were it not for this marathon, I don’t think I would have revisited it any time soon. As it is, I don’t feel it has much listenability although one day I may read the written version to see how close it is and maybe pick up on any aspects I missed from the reading. I will admit that single-voice audio tends to allow my mind to wander whilst listening to it, which can mean salient points are missed from time to time.

Review last edited on 24-10-24


External Reviews / Opinion pieces

Community Ratings


* We are using ratings from third party sites for this story because we do not yet have enough ratings on TARDIS Guide. Please spread the word and rate the story!

TARDIS Guide

Votes: 12
Average rating: 3.46 / 5

The Time Scales

Votes: 4
Average rating: 3.65 / 5


(Updates coming soon:)

Add the last X members who rated it here

Add number of Favs, and who they are, here

Ratings are from TARDIS Guide members only.

Other adaptations of this story:


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *