Skip to content
TARDIS Guide

Back to Story

Reviews

Add Review Edit Review

8 reviews

I adore the puppetry of Alpha Centauri. the little movements of their limbs and head alongside the blinks really create a believable personality for them despite being made of plastic and curtain materials. the ice warriors are so silly in this with the way they waddle like penguins. however the plot was boring and didn't warrant six episodes.


kawaii2234

View profile


This review contains spoilers!

C'est un épisode très intéressant. Il est vrai qu'il peut paraître long mais ça reste super divertissant. L'histoire des Peladons c'est incroyable de base.

L'histoire très complotiste dont Le Docteur est obligé de s'en mêler pour contraire.

Sarah Jane est un peu insupportable à pleurer et j'ai l'impression qu'elle n'a un peu servit à rien.

La reine de Peladon est très bien. C'est un retour très réussi. Néanmoins, il aurait fallut que cette histoire se fasse avec un autre Docteur, pour que cela aurait mieux marcher.

J'adore l'idée que les Ice Warriors redeviennent les antagonistes, en plus le chef de la sécurité (notez tout de fois qu'on ne voit pas la sécurité œuvrer au fil du temps des épisodes).

J'adore l'idée du culte d'Aggedor. Un peu triste que le Haroon soit fait qu'une seule fois dans cette épisode.

J'ai très bien aimé le conseiller Ortron, qui rappelle étrangement Hepesh, conseiller complotiste qui se fait bien voir devant le Roi (ou la Reine) et que dès qu'il est ailleurs, il fait de lui même les prises de positions. Ce serait bien de savoir si Ortron a un lien familial avec Hepesh ou non.

C'est un épisode qui ne peut pas être vu sans avoir regardé The Curse of Peladon et bien sûr sans avoir vu l'introduction de Sarah Jane, The Time Warrior.

This is a very interesting episode. It's true that it may seem long but it remains very entertaining. The story of the Peladons is incredible from the start.

A very conspiratorial story which the Doctor is obliged to interfere in to oppose it.

Sarah Jane is a bit unbearable with her crying, and I feel like she was a bit useless.

The queen of Peladon is very good. It's a very successful return. Nevertheless, it should have been done with a different Doctor, for it to have worked better.

I love the idea that the Ice Warriors become the antagonists again, plus the head of security (note however that we do not see the security operating over the course of the episodes).

I love the idea of the cult of Aggedor. A bit sad that Haroon is only made once in this episode.

I really liked the advisor Ortron, who strangely reminds me of Hepesh, a conspiratorial advisor who gets himself seen in a good light in front of the King (or Queen) and who, when elsewhere, takes positions on his own. It would be good to know if Ortron has a family connection with Hepesh or not.

This is an episode that cannot be viewed without having watched The Curse of Peladon and of course without having seen the introduction of Sarah Jane, The Time Warrior.

(Translation generated by AI, so mistakes are possible).


Voyager

View profile


Good to see a sequel. Alpha Centori is back again and has a lot to do tbf. The civil war is fine. Most of the cast is fine. As I've said before, I'm not a fan of the Ice Warriors, and i still think the regular ice soldiers are boring, but the commander was fine. This is also one that the six parts do feel too long.


Scottybguud

View profile


I've been pretty mixed on Sarah Jane up until this point, but this story completely turned me around on her, largely due to Elizabeth Sladen's phenomenal performance.

Only one Third Doctor serial left!
A+. Maybe A.

Azurillkirby

View profile


This review contains spoilers!

I've found listening to the audiobooks of the novelisations has helped me focus some of my thoughts about this story. I've always enjoyed it in the past and was of the general opinion it wasn't as bad as received wisdom suggested and that it had lots of good elements.

I was hoping my Peladon-centric rewatch would confirm this but sadly, I found myself a bit bored this time round and I've been pondering why whilst listening to the audiobook (which so far is a scene by scene retread of the TV version with nothing added, as far as I can tell, so far).

The Monster of Peladon is, sadly, a pale retread of Curse for the simple reason that it takes the setting, the characters and the atmosphere of Curse and dispenses with every single interesting aspect.

Curse has various alien delegates bickering and scheming. Monster kills the most interesting one off before the first episode has finished and just leaves us wih Centauri and Eckersley.

Curse has Centauri being a prissy, yet effective poltician. Monster has Centauri being a quivering nervous wreck, even more easily pressured into making bad decisions than it was in Curse. It also - bizarrely - has a worse 'costume' (the thickness of the curtain makes Centauri look clunky).

Curse has the glorious twist that the Ice Warriors are goodies. Now obviously that couldn't be repeated here but just making all the Warriors baddies is hugely lazy. Why not have a contingent of 'good' Martians turn up and discover a faction of bad Warriors and have the conflict between them - rather than stupidly-haired miners doing the same thing episode after episode - attack the armoury, run through the tunnels, get killed by the Aggedor ghost, run through the tunnels, get angry and cheer, run through the tunnels etc. Imagine the Warriors discovering a traitor in their midst in league with Eckersley. That could have been much more effective than what we got.

Curse has a brilliant role for Jo with her relationship with the King. Monster has Sarah bouncing between the control room and the tunnels with alarming repetition, being taken hostage by a succession of characters and believing the Doctor to be dead more than across the episodes. The glimmers of good stuff for her are in her throne room scenes - realising how they can get rid of the Federation troops and, significantly, giving Thalira a pep-talk about women's lib. Her role in the story - and Thalira's for that matter - could have been hugely improved by pairing them off and having them drive the plot in the palace while the Doctor was focussed on the efforts of the miners and the mystery of the Aggedor ghost. As it is, Sarah does very little in the story and isn't aided by being written as quite unpleasant in some parts (such as her reaction to Centauri).

Monster really does seem lazy and repetitive both of Curse and within its own episodes. There is good stuff and some great performances - Rex Robinson is good and Nina Thomas was better than I remember but it is definitely a step down from The Curse of Peladon.

The more I think about it, the more I think I need to drop my rating.


deltaandthebannermen

View profile


Don’t think I enjoyed this story so much more then I did I used to hate it now it’s fine character development right here


Rock_Angel

View profile


This review contains spoilers!

The Curse of Peladon is perhaps a surprising choice of story to write a sequel to – had another Pealdon story never been written I doubt fans would be clamouring for it, I am however glad that this story exists. Ever since The Three Doctors the show has felt more comfortable revisiting its own history and building on its mythos. In this case we get the rare treat of seeing the consequences of The Doctor's actions explored fifty years later.

It was a relief to see Sarah Jane's character enhabiting more of her original purpose in this story. She is a tough advocate of the women's liberation who wants to make a difference on Peladon (even if this is not handled particularly subtly). With modern eyes there is an interesting tension between the stories' mission statement to promote women's capabilities and the fact that The Doctor spends the story babying and talking over Sarah Jane, who pretty consistently accepts it with good nature. This isn't a major criticism, it is a huge improvement on Death to the Daleks, but when there are only a handful of women in a cast full of men it is difficult to not address the way women are represented in the show. Especially when the promotion of women's rights is a significant feature of the plot! Women's issues aren't the only problem here, it is a worry that most of the working class characters in this are complete idiots who don't know what's good for them!

I like the way the Ice Warriors are portrayed here, as an overbearing political force which puts minor colonies under extreme pressure. It furthers the 1970s EEC allegory from the initial Peladon story, looking at where political agreements can go wrong. This kind of real world evil makes them a more relatable and possibly more menacing threat to the audience.

Eckersley's reveal as a villain (or a character who doesn't care about Peladon either way) is nicely handled and was not entirely suspected. The aliens looked good with the exception of the new wooden faced creature in episode one (wonky eyes!). It would perhaps have been good to see some more new aliens as bar from the wooden faced man it was a partial selection of those seen in The Curse of Peladon.

The Doctor's (almost) death scene is wonderful. I really believe Sarah Jane's relationship with him, they have come a long way in four stories. This works as good foreshadowing for the next story - there are huge changes to come.

As with a lot of six partners this could lose a couple of episodes - but it was a good addition to the series.


15thDoctor

View profile


A win for feminism, miners' rights, and the space European Union, but ultimately not enough Alpha Centauri


greenLetterT

View profile