Review #45

The Death of John Smith

continuation of Human Nature

This second part was amazing. It did a really good job at continuing on from part one without really adding anything new or ruining it. It was so sad to see John Smith having to come to terms with the fact he has to die to save everyone in the village. The way the doctor defeated the family was pretty dark. Seeing tim at the end after fighting the war and being so old made me cry. Respect to all the soldiers that fought in the war 🫡. Part 2 gets a 10/10 and the entire story gets a 10/10. A really good story

When I watched this as a child, the (amazing) monologue at the end gave me a slight fear of mirrors, or rather... what might be in them.

A lot of what I said of Human Nature applies here.  The writing is solid, the cast and characters are great, and this episode in particular has a very strong look and feel to it.  Sure, the scarecrows can be a bit goofy, but the Family of Blood and their unique mannerisms more than make up for that.  The Doctor returning is a big moment here that leads to an even bigger moment when he defeats the Family of Blood.  The way he stops them is such a show-stopping moment, too.  It is a now legendary ending for any Doctor Who episode and, in my opinion, The Family of Blood is a masterpiece.  A truly creative and meaningful work of art I very much enjoyed and has held up on every re-watch since.

My word. How do you follow up a mid-season lull? This will do nicely! It makes you wonder why they never did another book adaptation after such a barn storming success like this. Obviously we don’t know which bits were Paul Cornell and which bits were Russell T Davies, but it also seems a shame that this is Cornell’s final outing - given the obvious quality on display here.

It feels like a mixture of classic and modern Doctor Who. There is a patient, talkative, literary quality peppered with moments of high adrenaline, edge of your seat drama, romance and fantasy. The old fashioned educational setting and the invisible spaceship remind me of Shada - but done right. It just *feels* very deliberately Doctor Who-ish.

I remember being so excited by seeing John Smith’s diary onscreen back in 2007 - the first time we saw that level of continuity in the new series.

The Doctor enters a self-contained dream world which unintentionally catfishes poor Joan. A touching tale. The doomed romance makes this a story which lingers in the mind long after it has finished. Jessica Hynes perfectly plays the poorly treated Joan with dreams of a life with John Smith. It’s a stellar cast all round - but she stands out. The emotional stakes are more than matched by David Tennant playing John Smith in his human form. This is David’s best performance in Doctor Who. Joan’s final question to The Doctor, asking whether anyone would have died if he had not chosen her home place and time as a hiding place, is a brutal blow.