The Sarah Jane Adventures S5 • Episode 3-4
The Curse of Clyde Langer
Reviews and links from the Community
Review of The Curse of Clyde Langer by Bongo50
I feel that I should preface this by saying that I am not a fan of The Sarah Jane Adventures: I have up watching it when I was watching it through (I will return to it at some point). That said, I watched this one in isolation and it was a lot better than I was expecting. My biggest issue with The Sarah Jane Adventures has always been the pacing, but this felt well paced throughout. The core idea felt really unique and it kept me engaged. The story also included some nice social commentary which mostly felt like it blended in very well (there were maybe one or two lines that felt a bit on the nose). I did feel that some of Sky's actor's acting was a bit wooden. My largest issue with the episode, though, would be the ending which just felt a bit rushed and overly convenient.
This review contains spoilers
Review of The Curse of Clyde Langer by WhoPotterVian
The Curse of Clyde Langer is not only from arguably the best Doctor Who spinoff so far The Sarah Jane Adventures but is also an absolute classic that would fit into the main show easily.
When Clyde (Daniel Anthony) pricks his hand on a totem pole during the visit to the Museum of Culture, everybody he knows turns against him apart from one - Sky (Sinead Michael). Clyde loses everything including a place to live and ends up living on the streets.
This is a kid's programme yet it explores the adult topic of homelessness better than any primetime TV show; it is dealt with delicately and with quite a bit of heart, not afraid to shy away from some of the harsh ways the homeless must live. It's a sweet and touching story, helped by the introduction of homeless girl Ellie Faber (Lily Loveless) who quickly becomes a friend of Clyde's in a world where he has no friends. The ending is tragic too, as he returns to find Ellie after the curse has been resolved only to find she is no longer there.
Daniel Anthony is absolutely at his best here; he gives a moving performance especially during the scene where his own mother (Jocelyn Jee Esien) kicks him out. You really feel sorry for him; Daniel Anthony was always the best child actor on The Sarah Jane Adventures and it shows here.
Lily Loveless is also great as Ellie and as the audience you are left hoping she'll find a way out of her difficult situation. I like to think if it weren't for Elisabeth Sladen's tragic death and the show had continued that Ellie would have returned later down the line as she is a great character played by a great actor.
When I watched this at the time, there was also an episode of Coronation Street dealing with the same issue and it was nowhere near as effective. The Curse of Clyde Langer shows homeless people to be just like us, only in a more difficult and terrifying situation than any of us could possibly imagine. It's an important world issue and one that it was nice to see a CBBC show teach kids about; that was what was great about The Sarah Jane Adventures - it treated kids like adults who could deal with watching serious issues represented onscreen rather than clueless idiots who need everything spoon-fed to them (there are many shows that do the latter).
Simply put, The Curse of Clyde Langer is an absolute masterpiece and deals with the issue of homelessness in a sweet and touching way. Anyone should watch this episode not just Whovians as it is a great piece of television for kids and adults alike. It's worth watching just for Daniel Anthony, who gives a moving performance as someone whose friends have turned against him.
This review contains spoilers
Review of The Curse of Clyde Langer by 15thDoctor
Sky is brilliant! They found an excellent young actor to play her and it’s a terrible shame that she gets such a truncated run on the show as she’s a little star!
There is a famous actor playing guest character Ellie, later better known for being in Skins. Rani’s got competition! She’s been on the streets for 2 years, but not so long that she can’t get their roots done! The romance was played really well, I am looking forward to seeing how it interacts with Clyde and Rani’s budding romance.
The rest of the plot is a little thin. Clyde and Sky work out what’s going on far, far after the audience has and you watch the same scenarios play out again and again. Luckily the cast are more than capable of handling the lacklustre script, giving all the oomph of any other story.
Community Ratings
(Updates coming soon:)
Add the last X members who rated it here
Add number of Favs, and who they are, here