The Catalyst

The first half is very distinct and stands out well against the other stories in series 2 companion chronicles. There is an interesting clash between the Edwardian and the alien that makes for a satisfying listen. As this aspect fades away in the second half things become a little more generic. Although there is a thoughtful, meaningful ending where Leela looks back towards the end of her life.

Louise Jameson does a marvellous job, but I don’t think subs in for Tom Baker particularly well when it comes to portraying The Doctor.

This series has been a bit mid. Hopefully this range improves in future series?

This is part of a series of reviews of Doctor Who in chronological timeline order.

Previous Story: The Valley of Death

I don't usually like Nigel Fairs' stories. I think his surreal stories don't work and are a bit shallow.

This is not one of those stories. It has some complex views on morality and the greater good. It's definitely character driven but I don't think the Doctor is portrayed very well.

He feels too serious and brooding against a threat that doesn't really live up to that.

Next Story: Empathy Games