Skip to content
TARDIS Guide

Review of The Eternal Dogfight by 15thDoctor

26 February 2025

This review contains spoilers!

This first instalment juggles too many competing ideas, with no unifying focus. The titular “eternal dogfight” – a clash between two species with thinly sketched motivations – jostles for space alongside Alice’s emotional subplot (returning home to reconcile with her supposedly deceased mother, now mysteriously alive). Add to this a couple of additional underdeveloped companions, one whose ability to “consume” antagonists feels more gimmick than plot device, and a David Bowie-esque rockstar character who still hasn’t done anything, and the Doctor zipping about on jetpacks. The result is a chaotic sprawl.


15thDoctor

View profile