Review of Castrovalva by Gibbypg
7 October 2024
This review contains spoilers
I'm going through the Davison era again with a friend now so what better time than to get reviews for all these stories up on this website. I absolutley adore this story, probably more than I should. Nonetheless I do think it holds up very well as both a cool story on it's own and an introduction for this new era. It was an interesting choice having the Doctor out of action for a lot of this story but I do think it works in showing what this incarnation is all about, especially in S19. The starting point of his character is someone who lacks the presence of what you'd expect from the Doctor; someone who is often overpowered and is very reliant on others. All in all this story does a great job of setting up what his character will be like for the rest of the season. Davison wonderfully portrays all the youthful energy, gentle demeanour and dry wit that will define this character.
I think this is a fantastically creative story as well. It's a lot crazier than a typical regeneration story and I love it for that. Things just seem a little off in Castrovalva and the way the discrepancies are slowly built up is great and I love the sequences of the characters running around getting stuck in loops and trying to make sense and explain what is going on. Ainley is great in this story as always and as far as the companions go, Adric may get shafted a little bit but overall Castrovavla does a much better job of balancing the three companions then other stories in S19. I just love this story so much because it feels very cosy; it's got that light and jovial feel that a lot of early fifth doctor stories have before it all starts to go wrong. The fifth doctor's first Tardis team is unbelievably cracked and I'm really happy to be revisiting this era and reexperiencing the wonder of Five failing to be a surrogate parent to his three gay children. 9/10 / 4½ stars.