Skip to content
TARDIS Guide
whitestar1993 Let me take it from the top...
United States

whitestar1993 has submitted 135 reviews and received 147 likes

Review of Lucky Day by whitestar1993

3 May 2025

Four good episodes in a row? Wow.

Overall, enjoyed this one. Basically Love & Monsters but not terrible. Didn't really watch last season so don't know Ruby much, so I think she was just okay. It was fantastic seeing Kate again, just wish Osgood was on the team still. The final15 and Conrad scene was the best 15 yet, loved the darker take on his character. Hope we see that more. Also thought the UNIT storyline was good, surprised we haven't got a story like that before, though I wish we get to see the aftermath of this episode.

Now for the negatives, the2007 scenes with the doctor were very bad acting. I also think this era's UNIT is a bit bland, other than Kate it just seems like 2D cookie-cutter characters. Also, another Doctor lite episode, really? With only 4 episodes?


whitestar1993

View profile


Review of A Blind Eye by whitestar1993

3 May 2025

This review contains spoilers!

A great finale for series 1. Loved that it was contained in one location, made it easier to follow and really help the plot. Was interesting to see 'Sissy' Pollard's story, and the connections to the Eighth Doctor and Charley. And that twist at the end, I did not see that coming!

Took a while to get into Gallifrey, but now I am interested in series 2.


whitestar1993

View profile


Review of The Inquiry by whitestar1993

1 May 2025

This review contains spoilers!

This was the first Gallifrey audio that I really enjoyed, with a cool twist and time travel shenanigans.

Don't mess with Romana, you don't want to be on her bad side lol. Narvin's mystery grows even deeper, at this point it's hard to believe how he becomes a fan favorite character.


whitestar1993

View profile


Review of The Well by whitestar1993

26 April 2025

Fairly strong episode so far. Great soundtrack and visuals, clever problem solving, and an interesting idea for the big bad.

Even though I knew the twist, it was well done. Though pretty unnecessary? Also I'm glad they didn't tie it into the pantheon arc.

The Doctor cries again... But it does actually makes sense story wise this time!

The last scene I'm mixed on, I hope the midnight alien didn't survive. If it did it's going to be overused. But if it's just meant to be a paranoid scene like the end of Blink, I'm cool with it.


whitestar1993

View profile


Review of Stop the Clock by whitestar1993

24 April 2025

Oh man, what an ending! Very satisfying way to tie up the arc. Everyone was on top form acting, and some great sound effects/"visuals", I could really picture what was going on, unlike the last two episodes.

The Red Lady twist with Padrac was great, (even knowing it ahead of time,) great way to end his character. I did find the last minute Caleera and Liv twist a little confusing? I guess it wasn't explained enough exactly what she did.

Overall I enjoyed Doom Coalition, much more than Dark Eyes.

Anyways, not too interested in Ravenous or Stranded, but thankfully this works as a great 'finale' arc/episode.


whitestar1993

View profile


Review of Ship in a Bottle by whitestar1993

21 April 2025

This review contains spoilers!

An incredible start to the last series of Doom Coalition! We get a three-hander with just The Doctor, Liv, and Helen. The raw emotions were really powerful, and we get a rare moment of the Doctor actually giving up. I really like Liv in this, she never gave up.


whitestar1993

View profile


Review of Lux by whitestar1993

19 April 2025

This review contains spoilers!

A very unique episode that I enjoyed, (other than Disney Plus' horrible ad placements...)

Positives:

  • Very good VFX in this episode, the first episode in this new era that I think looked on par with Flux.
  • I enjoyed Ncuti's performance this episode as well, I don't know what changed, but I prefer his acting this season better than last.
  • A very unique concept, which was fun.

Neutral:

  • I thought the fan/fourth wall break was a cool idea, though I think it went on a bit too long.

Negatives:

  • Again, I just wish this whole pantheon arc was done with, I don't really care about it. I wish this was just a standalone adventure instead of  shoehorning that arc in
  • Belinda seemed way too quick to switch her attitude towards the Doctor around. After last episode, I was looking forward to a more Donna-like companion, but I guess we are back to the same thing we've had with most other companions.
  • Edit: The music from Matt Smith's run really did not fit imo, the scenes they played in had nothing to do with what the tracks were originally for.

whitestar1993

View profile


Review of The Eighth Piece by whitestar1993

14 April 2025

I don't really know where to start. It was a decent story, however, looking at the character list right after listening, half of the characters I don't even remember being in this audio. Very confusing.


whitestar1993

View profile


Review of The Robot Revolution by whitestar1993

12 April 2025

A decent opener for the season, much better than Space Babies.

+ The pacing of the first half was great, the second half was a little uneven

+ Belinda was awesome, I can tell I'll like her. Nice to again have a companion stand up to the Doctor

+ I actually quite liked Gatwa's portrayal of the Doctor in this episode. Wasn't a fan of his acting last season, but it was a step up.

- The main enemy was pretty one dimensional, I didn't really like it.

- The every ninth word gimmick was neat till it was pretty much forgotten about.

- this is more of a personal nitpick, but I don't like the wide angle lenses they are using constantly.

- Of course the Doctor must cry at least once per episode 🙃

 

Overall a promising start, I'm cautiously optimistic. I don't like the 'pantheon' story so I hope there's more episodes like this that don't deal with that.


whitestar1993

View profile


Review of Absent Friends by whitestar1993

12 April 2025

This was the most emotional audio for me of this series so far. I also loved the fact that the stuff going on wasn't a result of any nefarious alien interference.

Great performances from all the cast, especially Liv and Helen. I feel so bad for them.


whitestar1993

View profile


Sorting, filtering, and pagination, coming soon!