I was very curious to rewatch this episode, since I listened to Jubilee recently, but I’m sad to say that I didn’t like it that much. I don’t remember loving it, but I expected to like it more as I’ve enjoyed every episode more this rewatch.

I haven’t quite worked out what didn’t work for me yet, but I think the change of setting was part of it. I loved the alternative timelines aspect of Jubilee, and the part I found scariest about that story was the people’s treatment of the Daleks, rather than the lone Dalek itself. By this I mean the trivialising of them, putting them in adverts, films etc. I also think Jubilee did a great job of bringing out the Nazi aspect of the Daleks.

However, in this story, I just don’t see the Dalek as scary or threatening, and I find Van Statten and Adam annoying.

The underground vault setting does create some tension because all the characters are trapped alongside the Dalek, but apart from all the soldiers getting murdered, I didn’t feel a real threat from the Dalek, precisely because it’s contained.

I also find the ‘soldiers don’t listen and shoot the Dalek and all die’ trope to be a bit tiresome now, I feel like it’s been in a lot of episodes.
The Doctor is amazing here, especially the scene where he tells the Dalek to kill itself.
I think I’m just generally a bit bored of the Daleks by now. And I’m not a fan of ‘The Last of the Time Lords’ stuff, which was expanded on in this story.

I think that this episode would work well as an introduction to the Daleks for a new audience, and some of the themes from the original story make the episode more compelling, but it didn’t work for me because I prefer the way it is executed in Jubilee.

What a fantastic start to this series, I was smiling for every second of it!

Tim Foley really got Thirteen and Yaz, and it was so lovely to hear Jodie and Mandip playing these roles again with so much enthusiasm.

The story had lots of great comedy moments, like the Doctor turning up with chickens (calling them Ian and Barbara was a nice callback), and only calling Gina’s mum ‘Gina’s mum’.

The twist that the dog was the vampire came as a complete surprise to me, and the ‘truth vampire’ was a nice addition to the Great Vampire lore. However, when the Doctor got bitten, I did expect them to go further and reveal some deeper truths that the Doctor was hiding from Yaz. That is the only thing I was disappointed by, and it’s a very minor one.

Yaz had some nice moments with her friends, I especially liked her scene with Daryl. I would love to see them return in another story later on. 

I also loved the references to other adventures that the Doctor and Yaz might have had, like Yaz mentioning the Forest of Cheem, and the hints of the series-long arc were really exciting! Who is the Tourist?

I was totally immersed in this story, it was a solid beginning to this series, and I’m very much looking forward to what is to come!

A great novelisation that expands on the original in some very interesting ways. Additional scenes are added, and the main story is interspersed with documents that give more context and history to Fenric, which are a fun read. However, I wasn’t a fan of making Ace’s attraction to Captain Sorin more obvious, instead of letting it remain implied like it was in the original serial.

Edit: this review doesn’t really reflect my current feelings on this episode.

I'm giving this episode half a star, and it's all for the Thirteenth Doctor.

I really hated this and I thought it was a complete mess. The main plot was resolved very quickly and easily, and it was a complete waste of the Rani. Being eaten by Omega was so stupid. Omega was also defeated very quickly, and I didn't like his redesign, it was nothing to do with his previous appearances or character.

The exposition during the beginning felt clunky, like the dialogue was being given to each character without any thought as to whether it was something they would actually say.

Anita showing up was nice, but saving the Doctor with a magic door was unsatisfactory and convenient. She also didn’t do much, and could have been replaced by anyone else.

I hated UNIT battling the bone monsters, it was so Marvel-esque, which is not something I want from Doctor Who. I didn't understand the focus on Poppy. Why was she suddenly Belinda's child? Why is Belinda nothing like the character from the season opener? Why did so much of her character this episode revolve around being a mother? Why did Fifteen regenerate when he wasn't injured or dying? What was the point of Thirteen showing up? What was the point of Omega and the Rani, if RTD wasn't going to utilise them properly? There was a lot of exposition (especially at the beginning) and made-up sci-fi explanations that explained nothing and only made me more confused.

I am so annoyed and angry that this was Fifteen’s regeneration story. Two seasons is short and it hasn’t felt like he’s had enough time to develop the character. There is also something uncomfortable about the fact that both the first female Doctor and the first Black Doctor regenerated into actors who have played  very popular characters in RTD’s first era.

I did enjoy the visuals, the Rani's bone palace looked amazing. I also loved the references to Looms, and of course, seeing the Thirteenth Doctor.

But, mostly I was very angry, betrayed, and disappointed.

This book was...weird, both the story and the way it was written.

To start with the positives: The narration was excellent. Christine felt very real and human, and her descriptions of the events and her feelings felt genuine. She related things to small moments in her life and to pop culture, and contradicted herself and jumped between the present events, her memories and her perspective from the future. I adored the scene towards the end of the book, where Christine challenges the Horror to a game of rock-paper-scissors, because it also showed how human she was. She used something as small as that game to decide the fate of the world, and woon purely by panicking and not choosing anything, which looked like picking stone, because she kept her fist clenched.
The first person point of view also made me feel more connected to Christine. Describing how the book ended at the beginning was an effective way of making me feel intrigued and wanting to continue.
The references to Bernice Summerfield and Dellah made the story and characters feel part of a wider universe as well, and I enjoyed reading Christine recounting Bernice's family history.

I also enjoyed how meta this book was. Each of the three parts was one of three notebook that Christine was writing in, which she referenced, and she talked about taking a photo of a sphinx that she might stick to the cover of her notebook. That photo she described is the cover image on the original edition of the book!

The twists were genuinely surprising to me and didn't come off as random or illogical. The reveal that Christine was created by Cwej for his ritual was hinted at a couple of times before the end, which means it didn't seem like it came out of nowhere. There were some cool concepts around Cwej's 'employers' (The Time Lords) and their agents. Each regeneration, they evolve and change to be more suited to whatever job they do, was fascinating and weird because it made them seem even more alien. They simply became machines to do what was asked of them.
There were also some interesting dynamics between Christine and Cwej around his separation with humans due to him working for the Time Lords and their genetic altering of him, and if Christine was 'real' because she came from the bottle universe.

However, despite this book being about the end of the world, it felt low-stakes. I think this is because I knew how the book would end (with the end of the world on October 12), so there wasn't a lot of urgency. I also think that Christine didn't attribute much importance to the world ending in her writing, because from her perspective (after these events had happened) she knew that she had only been around on it for a month and left soon after the Time Lords took it over.

I also was confused at points, because of the jumping around, but I imagine I will understand everything properly on a reread.

Overall, I had a really good time reading this. It feels different to other Doctor Who books I've read, and I loved the first-person narration and the weird sci-fi stuff like bottle universes and the Time Lord agents adapting and evolving with each regeneration.