Lions, Tigers, and Yearn

Prerequisites: The previous 11DC audios, and Series 7 of New Who.

The Yearn is notable for being far and away the lowest rated 11DC story. I was pretty curious to find out why, and the answer is that this is just a pretty basic base-under-siege tale at its core. Honestly, that's mostly it. I do have a few actual critiques though, mostly concerning the Yearn themselves. The idea behind them is cool, but frankly I found the explanation behind their motives and history to be way too abstract and full of blatant exposition for me to really track it. That scene was certainly not helped by the sound effects behind the alien voices, which were particularly difficult to understand. Other than that though, I liked this story well enough. The side characters are pretty good, Valerie's new romance is cute, and as always Dudman and Ingar are amazing together.

A perfectly solid story!

A 'base under siege' story is very much classic Doctor Who, and it's a story concept that always feels like it fits perfectly wherever it is it ends up being, here being no exception. Our core cast are nice, kept to just three extra characters which lets everyone have time to get uniquely characterised.

The threat itself is pretty solid, and I really like the ties to the mythology of the peoples, and the mechanics of how they function. Plus the imagery that's used here is really great, 'psychic energy panthers' is just a really really fun image.

Also I loved the romance we get in this episode, the character dynamic is sweet, always love a bit of queer rep, and the lampshading classic who companion's exits is also funny.

That all said, I think this is the 11/Valarie story not to blow me away. It's good don't get me wrong, but it's definitely 'solid' not 'stunning'. When that's the worst thing I can say about a story though, especially looking at the rest of the range... what's the opposite of damning with faint praise?

The Eleventh Doctor Chronicles #4.2 - "The Yearn" by Angus Dunican

The Yearn is the black sheep of the 11DAs it would seem. Unlike every other story from this range, the Yearn has a strangely low score of (at the moment) only 3.55/5. Due to this, it ended up being my most dreaded listen of this range but, upon actually listening to it, I found I was pleasantly surprised. This story absolutely does not deserve it's reputation and even beats out a couple of more beloved stories in my opinion, though I wouldn't call it an all-time great by any means.

On the planet Medrüth, the people are besieged by the Yearn; feline creatures made of an unknown energy. In an underground base, the Doctor and Valerie come across the last remnants of a scientific research team, but most of the team have been taken by some unknown force. As Valerie connects with young guard Roanna, the Doctor discovers some disturbing truths about the Yearn.

(CONTAINS SPOILERS)

The main complaint against the episode I gather from other reviews is its simplicity: it's a pretty standard base under siege with some cool ideas running around in it and, whilst I agree with some of those points and I'll get onto them later, I find this story rather comfortable in its simplicity, especially after All of Time and Space through me right into the meta deep end. This story is fun, its fast, it has some great dialogue and a standout side cast who actually had personalities, a surprisingly rare element in these types of story. Valerie gets a love interest in the form of Roanna and, though a forced romance plot can completely turn me off a story sometimes, this subplot actually felt pretty well developed in such a short space of time and I'm looking forward to seeing how it progresses into other audios. Also, yay, lesbians!

However, to call The Yearn anything special would be a lie; it's the middle child of this set and mostly exists to set up later plot threads. The Yearn are a cool antagonist but they're not incredibly well implemented and I was still a little unsure of some of the details surrounding their existence in the story (there's a lot of complicated back story that's not made entirely clear). And whilst the starting mystery is pretty stellar, it didn't feel like there was much behind it following the set up. It was all the Yearn, which was expected from the start but, hey, this story's main draw is the character development so it can't be criticized for this aspect too much.

The Yearn is by no means the worst of Series 7V, but it is definitely not as incredible as some of its counterparts and probably won't stick in my mind as much as something like The End did. Solid, but not exemplary.

8/10

Pros:
+ Great side cast that I found myself invested in
+ Wonderful, fast and (at times) hilarious dialogue
+ Great pacing, feels fast but doesn't skip over the slow moments
+ The subplot with Roanna was decently implemented and I'm excited to see where it goes
+ Lesbians

Cons:
- The Yearn, though good in concept, felt pretty poorly implemented and were more confusing than anything
- The mystery didn't last and was pretty bog-standard
- It's a pretty simple story and, after it's ended, you're not left with much sticking with you

Series 7V | Ranked:
14.
13.
12.
11.
10.
9.
8.
7.
6.
5. The House of Masks by Georgia Cook - 6/10
4. All of Time and Space by Ellery Quest (Tim Foley) - 7/10
3. The Yearn by Angus Dunican - 8/10
2. The Inheritance by Alfie Shaw - 8/10
1. The End by Rochana Patel - 10/10

Overall - 7.8/10

The Yearn: 8.8/10 The Yearn is yet another fantastic story in this range that has a few more issues than previous stories but still performs amazingly. Starting with what I loved, Valerie and 11 were yet again amazing and the chemistry between the two is great. The supporting cast here was pretty good but Roanna was amazing. The interactions between her and Valerie are amazingly written and are very poignant. I liked the Yearn a lot and thought they were interesting but was honestly a bit confused when it came to the explanation of what they were. Aside from that, the “trapped inside a base” concept is fairly typical but is done well here which I like a lot.

A well told story in the second Eleven & Valarie box set. While not as imaginative as the first, this story is very well done. While on the surface, this tale is a staple of Big Finish Doctor Who, this one has a few twists and turns that make it stand out on its own. The chemistry between Jacob Dudman and Safiyya Ingar is still here, and this story more than others really cements Safiyya Ingar's Valarie Lockwood as a great companion. The banter back and forth between Valarie and The Doctor is right out of the TV show. The guest cast is excellent, with a special note to Mia Tomlinson as Roanna. Overall, this is another cracker of a story in the ongoing series.