Thworping through time and space, one adventure at a time!

“THE WHITE SHIP – STORMY SEAS, STOLEN IDENTITIES, AND STEVEN IN THE SPOTLIGHT”

The White Ship returns the First Doctor and Steven to the realm of pure historicals, this time landing them in Normandy in 1120—a moment teetering on the brink of catastrophe. King Henry I is about to return to England, and Steven, thanks to a well-placed resemblance, finds himself mistaken for the king’s heir, Stephen of Blois. Unlike The Massacre, where the Doctor’s doppelgänger took centre stage, this tale cleverly shifts the classic formula onto the companion, plunging Steven into the political whirlwind of medieval royal succession.

This tale draws heavily on historical detail, with a tangle of period-accurate names and political players that at times overwhelm the listener. Much of the narrative unfolds via dialogue-heavy scenes in taverns, courts, and shipyards, with the Doctor playing diplomat at King Henry’s court while Steven tries to untangle the mess caused by his misidentification.

STEVEN TAKES THE LEAD

This is very much Steven’s story, both in narration and in structure. Peter Purves once again proves himself a master of the Companion Chronicle format, juggling narration and performance with impressive ease. His Steven voice is distinct from his older self, and he handles emotional beats with sensitivity—particularly during the shipwreck sequence. While the mistaken identity plotline feels undercooked, Steven’s proactive role in tracking down the TARDIS and dealing with the unfolding tragedy is compelling.

A SLOW BUILD TO TRAGEDY

If the first half suffers from pacing issues—largely due to an overload of historical exposition and long conversations—it does at least set the stage for the powerful second half. The build-up to the titular ship’s doomed voyage is steady, if a bit sluggish, but the pay-off is worth the wait. Part 2 sees the actual journey unfold with haunting detail.

The shipwreck itself is the clear highlight, and Purves delivers a chilling, immersive performance as Steven is forced to live through the horror of the White Ship’s demise. The soundscape—seagulls, crashing waves, panicked voices—is minimal but effective, with music choices that enhance the mood rather than distract. The fact that only two survivors—Steven and a butcher—emerge from the wreck gives the conclusion a sombre and surprisingly emotional edge.

NOONAN’S DOCTOR IN SUPPORT

Stephen Noonan, continuing to hone his interpretation of the First Doctor, fits this Companion Chronicle format rather well. He plays the Doctor with a slightly stylised tone, one that captures Hartnell’s energy without direct impersonation, and shows off his versatility by voicing several other characters, all distinct and believable. While the Doctor mostly remains in the background for this story, his scenes with King Henry and others add richness to the historical setting.

The chemistry between Noonan and Purves is excellent, echoing the dynamic from The Massacre—an apt comparison, given the companion-doppelgänger twist and the grim tone of the narrative.

MUSIC, MOOD, AND A STRONG FINISH

The gentle, mediaeval flute motifs and atmospheric sound design subtly elevate the experience, giving the tale a sense of time and place. It’s not flashy, but it complements the narrative beautifully.

One of the more pleasant surprises here is the epilogue. Unlike many early Doctor Who stories, The White Ship doesn’t rush its ending. There’s time for reflection, for emotional fallout, and for Steven to process what he’s just survived. That alone gives this tale a maturity that’s often missing in other Companion Chronicles.

📝VERDICT: 7/10

The White Ship is a thoughtful, slow-burning historical that offers a compelling showcase for Steven and a graceful nod to the show's earliest forays into serious, tragedy-tinged storytelling. While its pacing and overabundance of historical names may alienate some listeners, its second half—centred on the sinking of the titular vessel—is gripping and evocative.

With Purves at his storytelling best and Noonan continuing to grow into the First Doctor’s role, this is a subdued but ultimately rewarding entry in the Companion Chronicles range.

I'm pretty knowledgeable about history, but 1100s England is never something I'd look into a lot so I had no idea about the real disaster of The White Ship. The first part is pretty standard First Doctor and Steven messing around in history, but the second part is a harrowing description of the horrific shipwreck that leaves only Steven and a butcher the survivor. Listening to them struggle in the sea while walking in the rain definitely added to the feeling. It's a great historical, and can be seen as a precursor to the Doctor and Steven's blow-up in The Massacre.

this story I feel captured the 1st doctors era very well it was very good at that and Peter does a really good job on it