As close to perfection as a Doctor Who story can get. I has a slow burn to ramp up tension until the hopelessness and the horror reach it's peak. Cole comes off as an extremely likeable and flawed character with him trying to do the right thing but ultimately making everything worse. Jacobi takes a backseat in this one but he uses his screentime well to portray the masters as a cunning manipulator. This requires to listen to the mediocre The Good Master before this but it's worth it to hear this harrowing tale

It's been quite a while since I listened to the previous two stories. As such I didn't remember Cole from this audio, so I guess that may have dampened my initial reaction to this.

The first 40 minutes or so I wasn't really into. I guess it felt like nothing interesting was going on? Likable characters though. The Master also didn't really do much, I guess I am used to the NuWho Masters. I considered stopping...

That ending though, man that was great. Not sure what else to say about it then I didn't see or expect that coming at all. I'm curious to see how that Cyberman reveal ties into the next episode, which I am eagerly looking forward to.

This story was a masterpiece. I can find no faults with this story, the Master manipulating Cole to create a paradox to play into the next story is genius, and the War Master is one that I have no issue visualising sitting down in the TARDIS gardens with a glass of wine. I also enjoy how there's a large gap during this story, where the War Master can duck off and do whatever. The rise of a new kind of Cybermen was such a gut-drop moment, especially the moment when Cole activates Elidh's emotional inhibitor. This story feels relevant now more than ever, with the recent political events.

OH MY GOD?????

I vividly remember my experience of listening to Sky Man. I was on a four hour coach trip and was listening to all of Only The Good. As I stopped off at a bus station between trips, I remember being sat in the cafe as the most harrowing big finish audio I've listened to thus far (May 2024) played out. I have no words for this. It is just brilliantly awful. The story does such a good job of making you love these bumpkin, salt of the earth farmers, and you maybe even believe that Cole is gonna be able to settle down with Elidh and have a happy life there.

And then, it rips it all away.

The descent of the planet into becoming The Retribution is so chilling. The fact that a simple need to help people produced a race as destructive as the Daleks or Cybermen is so viscerally upsetting - Elidh gradually becoming barely unrecognisable from the sweet girl we meet her as hits especially hard. But the fact that the Master deliberately engineered this scenario to fuel his plan in the Heavenly Paradigm are what truly get me. All those comparisons to Wine throughout the story show how utterly callous he is. An entire planet of people who meant no harm to him are fuel for a mad plan to rewrite all of reality to his liking. In hindsight, all that grandfatherly attention he shows Cole is so, so damn evil. He knows what he's doing, and that's what makes it so upsetting.

The Sky Man singlehandedly elevates Only The Good into being S+ to me. Viscoid and Good Master are solid stories in their own right but. Wow. Holy s**t. It's gonna be hard to top this.