Skip to content
TARDIS Guide

Back to Story

Reviews

Add Review Edit Review

3 reviews

This review contains spoilers!

This is part of a series where you can follow me on my journey across time and space (more commonly known as Big Finish Productions)

You can find the original posts here: https://forum.tardis.guide/t/oh-no-big-finish-addiction/4799?u=the9thcyberlegion

 

What a nice one to start off on (what happens in it isn’t nice but I’m sure you get what I mean). This main range is an absolute gem by Paul Magrs. And that comes from a Mancunian himself. I’ll be honest, I had no idea this happened before I listened to it.

This adventure is a pure-historical (no aliens but they go back in time) where the Fifth Doctor (Peter Davison), Tegan Jovanka (Janet Fielding) and Nyssa (Sarah Sutton) crash into August 1819 after the TARDIS gets caught in the smog from the industrial revolution and falls into the garden of the house of factory owner and all-around idiot, Mr Hurley (Robbie Stevens). The usual stuff happens where Mr Hurley tries to take advantage of the TARDIS and at the end of part 1 when the Doctor realises where (or should I say when) is executed perfectly.

The way this story talks about real and horrific tragedies committed by the upper class that were overlooked at the time and also how it isn’t afraid to get real and dark is done really well and I want to thank Paul Magrs for this amazing main range installment.

The Peterloo Massacre - (10/10)


This review contains spoilers!

This is part of a series of reviews of Doctor Who in chronological timeline order.

Previous Story: Aquitaine


What an infuriatingly good story. What better way to show how unfair and unjust the system is than to make the Doctor himself utterly helpless to it. There's even some elements similar to Rosa where the Doctor is forced to be on the wrong side of history for a moment.

Every now and then Doctor Who does a historical tragedy and it's very often brilliant. The suspense throughout this story is incredible, you know exactly what's going to happen (mainly because of the title) and hearing it play it out was just so tense. The scene where the Reverend quietly read out the Riot Act and used it as their justification was horrifying.

I don't want to speak about the plot of this story too much because it's genuinely something that everyone needs to hear. It's tragic and there's no redemption at the end and that's what makes it so powerful. I had never heard of this event before and now I really wonder why the Doctor puts up with humans so much.


Next Story: Tartarus


One of my favorite doctor who stories of all time. I've always been a big fan of historicals, and to use it to tell a tale so full of death works wonderfully for the 5th doctor. It takes me back to watching his final season, with this theme of death in his wake, even if not his fault. This is what I think should be used as the main example for how to write a historical, with the Doctor simply having to take in the setting, instead of influencing it. I urge everyone to give this story a shot, you won't regret it.