Definitely better than the first one but not hugely amazing

Thworping through time and space, one adventure at a time!

"The Silent City: A Musical Mystery with Time Lord Secrets"

I’m listening to this story as part of the Fifteen Doctors, 15 Stories audiobook release.

The Silent City begins with Jamie stepping into a London bookshop in the 1960s, meeting the intriguingly named Professor Thascalos (a sneaky cameo by the Master), and acquiring a mysterious book for the Doctor. However, the real story unfolds when the Doctor and Jamie are transported to an alien glass city, setting the stage for a fantastical adventure.

The story excels in showcasing the unique camaraderie between the Second Doctor and Jamie. Frazer Hines effortlessly brings their relationship to life, capturing the playful banter, mutual trust, and unspoken loyalty that define their partnership. This emotional core anchors the narrative amidst its alien landscapes and action-packed sequences.

The glass city is an eerie yet beautiful setting, filled with strange, fantastical elements that invite curiosity. While not teeming with life, the environment is vividly described, pulling the audience into its otherworldly allure. This imaginative setting is one of the story's strongest assets, offering a refreshing departure from the typical Doctor Who locales.

The narrative takes its time to introduce the Archeons, but their eventual appearance is worth the wait. Their deep-seated grudge against the Time Lords adds a compelling layer to the story, tying it to the broader Doctor Who mythos. By making the Archeons significant in Time Lord history, Scott elevates the stakes and enriches the lore.

The final act is a standout, delivering a vivid and creative sequence of music and sound. Both the Doctor and Jamie are utilised to their fullest, showcasing their resourcefulness and ingenuity in a truly memorable showdown.

📝Verdict: 9/10

The Silent City is a beautifully crafted short story that captures the spirit of the Second Doctor’s era while offering a fresh, imaginative adventure. Its blend of vivid settings, strong characterisation, and intriguing Time Lord history make it a standout story, and the musical climax ensures it ends on a high note.