Skip to content
TARDIS Guide

Back to Story

Reviews

Add Review Edit Review

4 reviews

This review contains spoilers!

This is part of a series of reviews of Doctor Who in chronological timeline order.

Previous Story: The Merfolk Murders


I have really mixed feelings about 6 parters. They're almost always awful and dull. Just regular stories dragged out to 3 hours long for no apparent reason. It's especially boring when they're set in one location without any actual story to tell. This one isn't the worst I've done but I wouldn't say it's that good either.

The first two parts are excellent. The premise is just really interesting - the Doctor, Nyssa and Adric are trapped in a constantly evolving prison without any memories of how they got there. Tegan is on the outside, trying to break them out. When she does eventually make it in, she finds that they have no memory of her. A really great start, really suspenseful.

Unfortunately, it's quickly resolved and the team get their memories back. Then the story grinds to a halt as all 6 parters do and it turns into mindless action and running about. It just completely loses it's momentum in favour of having the characters get captured and recaptured and seperated. All the usual (boring) stuff.

It does pick back up a bit in the last part. The Doctor sends his companions away in the TARDIS and is forced to remain at the prison with three sisters. The sisters are interesting enough but I found it hard to distinguish between them. They all stay here for decades and the Doctor has to watch each of them grow old and die. It's really sad stuff and refreshingly emotional after the abysmally dull middle.

It all comes to a very abrupt end, as soon as the last sister dies the Doctor is attacked by the parasite that was plaguing the prison in the start of the story. It doesn't amount to much as the TARDIS quickly returns with no explanation of how or why the Doctor programmed it to return at this specific point beyond "the moment has been prepared for". And worst of all it leads into a cliffhanger!

This story has got some decent moments sprinkled throughout it's excessive runtime but past that it really doesn't have anything going for it beyond the excellent performances from the cast.


Next Story: The Darkening Eye


thedefinitearticle63

View profile


promising to be an epic 6 part adventure, it just turns out to be a long and unexciting plod. its one of the most disappointing releases from the fifth doctor range in recent years. its overly confusing and doesnt do a great job explaining itself, the concept sounds way better than the way it was actually executed. its 6 parts and yet ive got barely anything to say about it other than the cast do a relatively good job.


gothoperas

View profile


My love hate relationship with the 5th doctor adventures deserves a Jeremy Kyle episode


Rock_Angel

View profile


This review contains spoilers!

5️⃣🔽 = MIDDLING!

Thworping through time and space, one adventure at a time!

“THIS JAILHOUSE NEEDS MORE ROCK!”

This story is off to a rough start; it’s unclear who is who, where we are, and what’s going on. And even after it’s slowly explained to us what is going on, I’m still quite lost and have a hard time getting a grip on the characters and the plot. I like the general idea, though, of a prison planet populated by more or less unstable inmates.

The most intriguing part about the first two episodes is everyone forgetting who Tegan is. Another interesting aspect is Ivan and his quirky persona.

The story slowly reveals new layers and twists that keep the adventure going at a decent pace. But even then, it only occasionally manages to remain entertaining while mostly trudging along and having no business being six parts long. It then ends at a cliffhanger, supposedly leading straight into next year’s first 5th Doctor box set.

The cliffhangers and their immediate resolutions are great, and the cast is generally superb—this goes for the regulars as well as Philip Hurd-Wood (Ivan) and the two Starclair sisters in particular. Andrew Wincott voices Beyond in the final part, and his interactions with the Doctor are also pretty nice.

RANDOM OBSERVATIONS:

The constantly changing surroundings of Beyond bring to mind the slowly changing layout of the spaceship in Wild Blue Yonder.


MrColdStream

View profile