Skip to content
TARDIS Guide

Back to Story

Reviews

Add Review Edit Review

2 reviews

This review contains spoilers!

What a cleverly written finale for this little boxset, so enthralling and keeping me guessing throughout! This episode really highlights how well actors can shine when writers put their faith in them and give them a constrained episode to show their stripes.

I really like the way that the Doctor starts off fairly quiet, but as the story continues, he becomes more and more aggressive and hostile as he confronts the three other cast members. It's a nice little nod to his tenure as a whole, where he is, most of the time, kind and innocent, but by the end he's determined, commanding and powerful. Nyssa spends most of the time in the background, which is a little disappointing. but it's nice for this Doctor, who is usually around his friends, all on his own.

The Rasht is a brilliant villain - so clever, creating doubt and concern in the audience as we don't know who it is - like I said, it's constantly shrouded in mystery, but in retrospective it's so obvious who the imposter was, and it's that subtle buildup that makes this story so brilliant and engaging. I felt like the ending was a little rushed, but I don't mind for the drama that ensues between the characters in the rest of the story.

I love the meta jokes this story goes to make about a behind-the-scenes, directors commentary that it's set during, referencing the commentaries that are done in the Classic Who DVDs, and more recently the Collection Boxsets - the format of this story is excellent, confined to a small, claustrophobic space and allowing the actors to focus on performing vocally, rather than having to voice any physical actions.

The dialogue for this story is phenomenal, constantly witty and interesting. The cast members are all different and contribute their own element to the episode, with the grumpy lead star often criticising the dull comments of his co-workers, the enthusiastic director bouncing off the others and Johanna constantly interrupting everyone with her excitability - they're all excellent, innovative and hilarious side characters that this story whizzes by as you're enjoying every second, and the imposter reveal is surprising!

The score is brilliant as well, going over the top with an impressive orchestral score setting a scary and imposing soundtrack to accompany the actors' horror-stricken performances, really raising the stakes and constantly memorable.

Favourite Line: "It's not me! I've got a BAFTA!"

A phenomenal conclusion to this set of stories - one average episode, three brilliant ones and they're really worth the listen, really great if you're still in the Halloween mood. Brilliant pacing, the character work is superb, awesome actors and a lot of enjoyment.


Ryebean

View profile


This review contains spoilers!

This is part of a series of reviews of Doctor Who in chronological timeline order.

Previous Story: Doing Time


I love Big Finish stories with experimental formats and this is an incredible example of that. Framing it as an audio commentary is just genius. It leads to so many funny moments and perfectly captures how bland so many audio commentaries actually are. The format elevates what would probably be a fairly mediocre story into something great.

The cast here especially are on top form. All of them sell their supposed roles really well. The only issue I had with this story, and it's a fairly minor one, is that the background music was really off-putting and intrusive in a lot of the story. It seems like it's supposed to be part of the soundtrack of the movie they're watching but it just feels like a generic Big Finish score and doesn't fit at all with the DVD commentary style.


Next Story: 1001 Nights (My Brother's Keeper)


thedefinitearticle63

View profile