Skip to content
TARDIS Guide

Back to Story

Reviews

Add Review Edit Review

3 reviews

It's crazy to think this might just be Chris Chibnall's best bit of writing for Doctor Who, written as a way of giving Brian Williams (a character he created) some closure following the ending of The Angels Take Manhattan and I'm glad he did it. For all of Modern Who's boasting about being more dramatic, it tends to ignore some of the wider impacts on other characters outside of its leads. Let's not forget there was a whole subplot about Amy's parents vanishing and after Series 5 they may as well have stayed vanished. A companion's family reacting to losing their loved one forever should be a big deal and warrant some kind of attention, so I'm glad Chibnall pushed for this to be made. It's a very nice emotional sendoff for the character as well as closing the book on Rory who just gets kind of forgotten about in the actual episode once he disappears.


DanDunn

View profile


loved this little minisode


Rock_Angel

View profile


This review contains spoilers!

It’s going to sound harsh, but I’m glad that this didn’t get filmed. It’s sentimental claptrap, it’s derivative of Blink in the extreme. I don’t feel it adds anything. It wouldn’t act as an emotional bookend to The Angels Take Manhattan and it would undermine the next episode if it was put at the end of The Power of Three, so I totally agree with the production team not filming this one. A close shave!


15thDoctor

View profile