Skip to content
TARDIS Guide

Overview

Released

Wednesday, December 9, 2015

Written by

George Mann

Publisher

Titan Comics

Pages

22

Location (Potential Spoilers!)

Lumin's World

Synopsis

The Eighth Doctor and Josie Day start a universe-wide investigation! First stop - Lumin's World, home to a raging war between the near-extinct Calexi and the crystalline Spherions! When Josie is wounded in the crossfire, it's up to the Doctor to strike a peace - and find a cure - before she dies!

Add Review Edit Review Log a repeat

Edit date completed

Characters

Reviews

Add Review Edit Review

2 reviews

A fairly Standard Doctor Who Adventure carried by our two great Leads (8 & Josie). I think it's fairly enjoyable with some great Set Pieces here and there. The Art remains the same in Quality.

Admittely my Opinion on this whole Miniseries is fairly conistent in most regards, so I recommend reading all of my Reviews and in Order.

 


RandomJoke

View profile


This review contains spoilers!

A more casual adventure for the Doctor. The cosmic coordinates from the note lead the Doctor and Josie to a war zone between a race of cat people and living crystals who want to take over their planet.

If you exhaled heavily and thought: ‘Now the Doctor will be outraged by the war and talk about other ways to resolve the conflict,’ you're right! (This remark is significant for Ukrainian readers. Right now, we are in a war against Russia, where we are fighting for survival as a country and a nation, so any remarks like ‘we just need to stop shooting and negotiate’ are perceived negatively.) As if someone expected something else. But to be fair, other solutions do make sense in this story. Because the whole massacre started because of a misunderstanding in the style: there have been no living crystals on the planet for a thousand years; meanwhile, cat people colonise the planet; the living crystals return, don't know that the cat people are an advanced nation, and start to mess up the planet, because that's how they reproduce.

Like... In this context, I don't even mind the Doctor's calls that there is another way besides war, because well... in this situation there really is... the barrier to understanding was the language barrier, which could not be overcome, because the crystals communicate purely through sound frequencies without any resemblance to words, unlike the cat people, who have ‘normal’ language.The Doctor was able to talk to the crystals and simply transferred them to another, already uninhabited planet. I can't even criticise the anti-war message in this story.

Basically, it's a nice, pleasant story. It's not a star-studded affair, but it's very smooth and doesn't ruin the series.

This review is a translation of a part of my Ukrainian-language text, the original can be found here: https://www.mzut-podcast.com/post/stari-doktory-novi-pryhody


Yar_Nazarenko

View profile


Open in new window

Statistics

AVG. Rating46 members
3.51 / 5

GoodReads

AVG. Rating494 votes
3.97 / 5

Member Statistics

Completed

83

Favourited

2

Reviewed

2

Saved

0

Skipped

1

Owned

9

Quotes

Add Quote

Submit a Quote