Skip to content
TARDIS Guide

Overview

Released

Thursday, November 8, 2018

Written by

Una McCormack

Pages

256

Time Travel

Unclear

Location (Potential Spoilers!)

Adamantine

Synopsis

Deep below the surface of the planet Adamantine lies a crystalline wonder world of lava seas and volcanic islands, home to living rock-people.

But when the Doctor and her friends arrive on Adamantine they find it under threat. The seas are shrinking, the magma is cooling, and mysterious, fatal seething pools are spreading fast.

Something has come to Adamantine – but what does it want? Fearing an invasion is underway, the Doctor must lead an expedition to the surface of the world to save its molten heart...

Add Review Edit Review Log a repeat

Edit date completed

Characters

How to read Molten Heart:

Reviews

Add Review Edit Review

2 reviews

This review contains spoilers!

It's interesting to see McCormack try out a concept she will later nail in Caged (with the 15th Doctor). It's clear that she likes to think up a good alien species with a unique world and outlook. But it just works so much better in her later book. Contrasting the two demonstrates why.

In Caged, just as in Molten Heart, we start with the main character. In both cases, an adventurous young girl somewhat at odds with her small community by dint of her adventurousness. But in Molten Heart, we stay with this character for just one short prologue chapter before the Fam arrives. In Caged, it's a good chunk of the book. We get a real feel for our heroine. We are rooting for her and care about her before the Doctor and their companion(s) arrive. There is no such feeling in Molten Heart.

The emotional beats hit harder in Caged. It gives us the confusion of an alien abduction and the doubts of the abductor and we feel both. Molten Heart gives us only what we can see coming a mile away.

This makes Molten Heart fascinating, because in it we can see the rough draft of some ideas that are better realized in McCormack's later, excellent book. I'm an Una stan and it's cool to see her improve from this book, which I didn't care for, to the other book, which is among my top DW novels.

Separately, this book once again underlines a problem with the Fam. The TARDIS has too many people and they never get interesting development. This book should have sidelined two — and I mean really sidelined; have them left at home on the TARDIS playing a game that we cut back to for ten pages total — and focus on just 13 and Ryan or just 13 and Yaz. I would love a larger TARDIS team that played with this and if it won't happen in the show, maybe it ought to happen in these spinoff novels.


jiffleball

View profile


I really dug this adventure (pun intended) the first half of this adventure. I feel like the relationships and dynamics between the TARDIS team are the strongest I’ve ever seen them, and honestly exactly what I want from a 13th Doctor novel. On the other hand, once we get into the classic who style cave runaround for the majority of the novel, I definitely checked out emotionally. Cool book, but I lost interest about halfway through and I never got it back.


PexLives

View profile


Open in new window

Statistics

AVG. Rating40 members
3.61 / 5

GoodReads

AVG. Rating532 votes
3.76 / 5

Member Statistics

Read

64

Favourited

4

Reviewed

2

Saved

4

Skipped

2

Quotes

Add Quote

Submit a Quote