If there was one episode I'd defend to my last breath, it would be 'Hell Bent'. 'Heaven Sent' has received unanimous praise and deservedly so, but I'd argue that it's not as great or as complete as 'Hell Bent'. Clara is now and forever my favourite companion and favourite Doctor!

New Who Review #129

Hell Bent

This story was alright. It's the weakest from this three parter but it Wraps up Clara's death nicely. I like how the doctor can't let go even bringing himself to killing a timelord and triggering their regeneration. It was weird seeing the doctor choose violence because that isn't who he is but I like how it shows how much he cares about Clara. Having the Sisterhood of Karn here felt odd I don't know why they were here but sure I guess. The design of the Sliders were creepy almost giving off a vibe of spooky to them and the fact they just lurk about in the depths just adds to that. I thought it was sad that the doctor had to forget clara and who she is and Clara's ending was nice. Overall a good three part story that sees my favourite companion off and brings back the timelords & Gallifrey. 7/10

This is a brilliant closing story for The Doctor and Clara. A fantastic payoff for anyone who has followed their story since the beginning. And a different kind of tragedy for our hero who will never remember Clara again. I’m glad she escapes her certain fate, it seems right.

This is the best of the four performances from Maisie Williams, even if her presence in the series is hardly needed. Capaldi and Coleman steal the show with a highly emotional performance that connected well enough for me to forgive the stories’ flaws.

You have to put the whole hybrid stuff aside to fully enjoy proceedings. It doesn’t make the slightest bit of sense. The idea that this ill defined prophesy could be taken as seriously as portrayed across this three parter is ridiculous. It’s so easily dismissed, which is crazy given the lengths the Time Lords go to to torture The Doctor.

Beyond this though you finally see a satisfying series of sequences on Gallifrey and how it’s people respond to The Doctor since the events in the 50th anniversary. The Time Lords and Ohelia are well drawn and propel what is more of an emotional rather than plot driven story.

I don’t think I appreciated Clara enough at the time. I will miss her.

Boy did fans have things to say when this was over. Admittedly there was no way the follow up to Heaven Sent could live up to its predecessor, but I think we can all agree it still could’ve been a lot better. Before Chris Chibnall and his run of terrible finales, including The Timeless Children which fans are still feeling raw about over five years later, we had Steven Moffat returning the Doctor to Gallifrey, something that Modern Who fans had been waiting for since the very beginning, and what we got was about twenty minutes of meandering with the Doctor hanging out in the barn Moffat seemed to love revisiting and reminding us of just how far the Time Lords had fallen since The War Games. We get a somehow lamer depiction of Rassilon than The End of Time, the Doctor waltzes in and takes over as ruler of Gallifrey while everyone keeps ominously mentioning this “Hybrid” creature we’re all supposed to be afraid of for whatever reason, and then Moffat decides to completely circumvent the death of Clara, at which point we ditch Gallifrey entirely and reveal the whole hybrid deal was complete horsesh*t while giving us a much weaker departure for Clara where the Doctor’s memory is wiped and she’s free to travel forever.

If you forgot your first time seeing this or weren’t around, this was looked at as one of Doctor Who’s major rage quitting finales. The wasted return to Gallifrey, doubling down on how pathetic the Time Lords are, rewriting the death of an unpopular companion, constantly teasing us with the series story arc only for it to amount to nothing and giving us yet another “Everybody lives!” resolution. It was the episode where people finally lost their patience with Moffat and were calling for him to leave, in tandem with Heaven Sent it’s like getting the best and worst of Moffat. Heaven Sent being Moffat the inventive writer we all fell in love with during RTD’s era, and Hell Bent being Moffat the showrunner with endless fan service, continuity references no one cares about, disappointing endings and being in love with his own vision of how Doctor Who should be. It’s honestly poetic, especially given the titles of the two episodes.

Coming back to Hell Bent almost ten years later, I will admit I’m not as filled with anger towards it now as I was back then. Yes it is definitely the weakest of the three episodes making up the Series 9 finale and no it’s not a good ending and Moffat really should’ve done a lot better than this (ya know, like one episode earlier!). But like any wounds, time does heal what this story left behind gradually, for one thing it’s considerably better than the finales we were in for later down the line. The Time Lords being an absolute joke is par for the course with Doctor Who to the point where there’s just no point expecting anything else. I’m probably in the minority, but I’m not missing them after being killed off by the Master in Series 12, I’m sure someday they’ll find a way back and be just as useless all over again, but honestly getting nuked offscreen by the Master I consider that a mercy killing! Retconning Clara’s death really should’ve been obvious going in as Modern Who is a show that’s cried “Bad Wolf” way too many times when it comes to killing off companions, and honestly even Classic Who doesn’t get a free pass considering they did almost the exact same thing with Peri.

The whole hybrid deal is indefensible, it’s like a parody of how a Modern Who series story arc plays out, easily the worst of the show, and yes I do utterly hate the Timeless Child story arc (the reveal of it being the Doctor not the actual concept itself), but at least we actually got something from it!!! All we get is Moffat not really understanding what a hybrid is supposed to be…

“What if the hybrid isn’t one person but two”

Because that’s not a hybrid! It’s two separate things!!! This is the same logic as calling two horses a single horse with two heads and two bodies!!! Funnily enough, The Timeless Children actually did a better job with this story arc if you think about it, in that episode Gallifrey’s a ruin, the Time Lords are all dead and the ones left standing in its ruins are the Master who’s a Time Lord merged with the Cyberium and the Cybermen who’ve now converted Time Lords. So there we are! Chibnall writes one of the worst finales in the show’s history and he inadvertently fixes the worst story arc in the show’s history! Go figure.

Amidst all its faults though, Hell Bent is still well produced and well performed, it really is the markings of how great the cast is that they act this material to the best of their abilities and almost make it work. The ending being a flip of the coin between either the Doctor or the companion losing their memory, a weirdly common trope throughout Doctor Who. I can certainly understand what Moffat was trying to do with the more definitive ending for the Doctor and Clara’s relationship, the Doctor having seemingly overcome his grief in Heaven Sent, but is so consumed by the temptation of saving Clara again that he leaps at it, putting the universe in danger and uncertain of how far he will go. I can get behind that idea if we didn’t have to sit through his usual bag of tricks

That being said, collectively I do enjoy watching these three episodes together as a single story, in many ways it’s the quintessential Steven Moffat story, everything we love and everything we hate about his show running years, and revisiting it almost a decade later, there’s something I kind of admire and appreciate about it. Who knows, maybe someday we may say the same about Chibnall’s works…though I doubt it.

This would be an all timer finale perhaps even the best of the show? A shame it's bogged down by the hybrid prophecy/ general Gallifrey lore. It's hardly mentioned throughout the series and is framed in a massively confusing way. A threat to the time lords? But they're gone aren't they? Lost in time somewhere I thought? Oh no, wait - as of the last 5 minutes of last weeks episode they're back! There wasn't a big enough deal made out of it for that part of the episode to work. However, everything involving 12 and Clara is predictably incredible - genuinely one of the best doctor/companion chemistries in the show and eventually the payoff to the hybrid is a good enough answer for me. Clara's ending for me isn't as final as I'd like and isn't as hopefully bitter-sweet as any of the previous companion departures, just seems like Moffat really didn't have it in him to commit - he doesn't like endings.

The slightly less peak second part to heaven sent

Amazing end to one of (if not the) best series in Doctor Who (Classic included). Clara is one of my favourite companions (up there with Ace and Charley). Everything from the 8th series onwards has led to this. Her (toxic) relationship with the Doctor is given full focus in this episode, and the repercussions are enormous. The Doctor being cruel and cowardly is not out of character here, he is grieving and lets go of everything he believes in exchange for Clara's life. The episode calls him out on this, and, as he says at the end, he will make amends.

The 12th Doctor is my favourite just based on how much character development he gets throughout his 3 seasons. His era is so much fun to watch as you see him grow from a grumpy idiot to The Doctor (the definite article, you might say).

totally forgot that the general is such a rat for being the one to banish rassilon only to turn around and tell 12 off like "ummm it was kinda mean banishing him sir... he was a good man once..." tbh i would have shot him too after that

I do not care about Clara Oswald. How do you follow up Heaven Sent THIS badly?!

This very much should have been a good story. We're back on Gallifrey! We're doing cool stuff with Rassilon and seeing new places on the planet! The Doctor's president now! These things should make for an unforgettable episode. Instead, Hell Bent is best left forgotten, Most of the Time Lord stuff kind of feels like background to the main focus which is on Clara, the Doctor, and Me. What little we did get of Gallifrey felt muted in its creativity and execution.

Little details like Clara's growing horror at the situation, acted really well by Jenna Coleman by the way, or Peter Capaldi playing Clara's theme at the end - there are small hints of what could have been a quality story. Instead, it is an enormous faceplant after Heaven Sent. An embarrassing one only made less embarrassing by the Chibnall era.

Boy, did Maisie William's character go nowhere. She is SO awkward in these stories and it badly affects how I view the performances in Hell Bent. If I didn't know her from Game of Thrones I really would think she was a rubbish actress, and absolutely feels miscast for the role. Otherwise, the performances of Capaldi and Coleman really go a long way to provide some weight to an otherwise bizarre and disappointing finale. I still don't really get what the point of her, or the whole Hybrid story line was here. I doubt Moffat could even tell us.