Gave it a 3/5 because I thought the concept was really cool, but the execution fell kind of flat for me. I wish they would have done this as a two parter to be honest.

It's the kind of episode I think could have been really fun if they leaned into the premise a little more.  I like the idea of a spooky story featuring old-timey film stuff.  Yet I really struggle to get any sort of impression out of From Out of the Rain whatsoever.  It's just kind of bland and boring.  Not obnoxiously bad like some of the worst of Torchwood, but not terribly moving or meaningful either.  It feels like a bit of a waste of time, really.

A solid 3 stars because what we lacked in characterisation we more than made up for in aesthetics, tension, and atmosphere. A bonus half a star because I am a simple person: I see a good clown design, I have a fantastic time

This is a fantastically eery and suspenseful story; it's like a typical Doctor Who hide-behind-the-sofa episode, but in a spin-off rather than the main show itself. I love the concept of the Night Travellers (beings who steal your last breath) , and the use of the fairground music whenever the old film reel is being used is satisfyingly creepy, almost characterising the danger that the reel poses, a bit like how drum beats represent the Jumanji board game in Jumanji.

Those sequences when the people from the film reel come out of the big screen in the cinema is so cleverly done with the CGI work; it's sort of like watching a twisted version of Cinemagique from Disneyland Paris!

The Night Travellers MUST return in some form of Doctor Who or Torchwood fiction. They are EASILY one of the best monsters to come from one of the Doctor Who spin-offs; everything about them just oozes menace. They really capture your attention whenever they are on-screen, and they could easily come back in a Big Finish, a comic or in Doctor Who on TV, seeing as the end of the episode teases a return that so far has never happened.

Come on, Chibnall or Nicholas Briggs! Bring back the Night Travellers, one of you!

I appreciate Peter J Hammond might be an old school legend of British television but this entry suggests he was past it by this point in time - particularly stagey writing throughout.