Skip to content
TARDIS Guide

Overview

Released

Tuesday, December 29, 2020

Written by

Eugenie Pusenjak

Narrated by

Jacob Dudman

Runtime

44 minutes

Inventory (Potential Spoilers!)

Psychic Paper, Sonic Screwdriver

Location (Potential Spoilers!)

Skaz

Synopsis

On Skaz, speaking costs money.

Aymius Todd is trapped in a police interrogation. They want to know about his links to the Garrulous Liberation, and his encounter with a man called the Doctor. But, Aymius is running out of words, and if he can’t afford to finish his story, then he’ll never be able to speak again.

Winner of the The Paul Spragg Memorial Short Trip Opportunity 2020

Add Review Edit Review Log a repeat

Edit date completed

Characters

How to listen to Free Speech:

Reviews

Add Review Edit Review

3 reviews

This review contains spoilers!

А ось і друге оповідання майже без Доктора! Й неочікувано детективний процедуал — майже все оповідання це сцена допиту. А сам сюжет — критика класової системи, хоч і трохи в лоб. Але спишемо це на короткий обсяг і недостатній обсяг для розкриття. Бо давайте чесно, ось ця тема…

I was conscious of my own tongue chip, which felt hot and heavy in my mouth. Direct line to my bank account. Each word cost one Drooble. Always been that way on Skaz. You got the chip on your sixteenth birthday, and from then on, you paid to speak. And I only had a few hundred Droobles to my name. I didn’t want to be speaking unnecessary words in the week before my wedding.

… не дуже віє оригінальністю. Мені, до прикладу, відразу згадався фільм Час з Тімберлейком в головній ролі. Але як гіпертрофований інструмент для висвітлення того, що в багатих людей більше фінансових можливостей продвинути свої ідеї та слова ніж в звичайного люду — зійде.

І хоч, швидше за все, авторка мала на меті критику капіталізму (куди ж без неї), мені здається, що в оповідання є великий потенціал киритки конкретно олігархії та контролю мільйонерів над медіа та соц. мережами. А ніж сліпої критик капіталізму як такого.

Цей відгук є частиною більшого тексту, джерело: https://www.mzut-podcast.com/post/the-paul-spragg-memorial-short-trip-opportunity-2016-2024

And here's the second story, almost without the Doctor! And unexpectedly, it's a detective procedural — almost the entire story is an interrogation scene. And the plot itself is a critique of the class system, albeit a bit blunt. But let's chalk that up to the short length and insufficient depth for full development. Because let's be honest, this theme...

I was conscious of my own tongue chip, which felt hot and heavy in my mouth. Direct line to my bank account. Each word cost one Drooble. Always been that way on Skaz. You got the chip on your sixteenth birthday, and from then on, you paid to speak. And I only had a few hundred Droobles to my name. I didn’t want to be speaking unnecessary words in the week before my wedding.

...doesn't feel very original. For instance, it immediately reminded me of the movie "In Time" with Justin Timberlake in the lead role. But as an exaggerated tool to highlight that richer people have more financial means to advance their ideas and words than ordinary people — it'll do.

And although the author probably intended to critique capitalism (how could she not), it seems to me that the story has great potential for specifically critiquing oligarchy and the control of millionaires over media and social networks, rather than just a blind critique of capitalism as such.

This review is part of a larger text, source: https://www.mzut-podcast.com/post/the-paul-spragg-memorial-short-trip-opportunity-2016-2024

(Translation generated by AI, so mistakes are possible).


Yar_Nazarenko

View profile


The concept is perfect for a short Doctor Who story, and it’s well explored in the first half. Unfortunately the protagonist is very boring, there’s not much to him other than being a good person and a bit of an everyman. Made worse by the fact that the upper class villains are cartoonishly drawn. The moral of the story is so blindingly obvious that you already have a firm grasp of it within the first 5 minutes.


15thDoctor

View profile


A short trip set in a really interesting world where it costs money for every word you speak, so only the rich can say what they like. Clearly it's an allegory, but it is handled well, with the Doctor mainly in the background and the focus on a character who is short of cash and so has to choose his words wisely. The choice of the famously talkative 10th Doctor is a good one, as his rambling contrasts sharply to the short, to-the-point, speaking style of the main characters.

It will come as no surprise, given the title, that the story resolves around the desire for free speech, and this aspect of the story works well. There is also a kind of clumsy romance sub-plot which obviously exists to highlight the difference in speech patterns of the wealthy and the poor, but felt unnecessary otherwise. My biggest issue was that the speech patterns of the poor people were not short enough. Several times the main character added an expression, a phrase, or a few extra words which were simply not necessary. A life of counting every word would likely have taught everyone how to say the absolute minimum words in any situation.

Overall, a fun story in a very clever world which made good use of the 10th Doctor and did not include a spurious alien invasion.


efficacy

View profile


Open in new window

Statistics

AVG. Rating104 members
3.66 / 5

GoodReads

AVG. Rating173 votes
3.99 / 5

Member Statistics

Listened

169

Favourited

11

Reviewed

3

Saved

1

Skipped

1

Quotes

Add Quote

Submit a Quote