Stories Comic IDW Comics Final Sacrifice 1 image Overview Characters Reviews 1 Statistics Related Stories Quotes Overview Released Wednesday, July 21, 2010 Written by Tony Lee Artist(s) Matthew Dow Smith Cover Art by Matthew Dow Smith Colourist(s) Charlie Kirchoff Letterer(s) Neil Uyetake, Robbie Robbins Publisher IDW Publishing Pages 100 Tropes (Potential Spoilers!) Fixed point in time Inventory (Potential Spoilers!) Sanctuary Base 6 space suit Location (Potential Spoilers!) Unnamed planet Synopsis On a war-ravaged alien world, the Doctor and Emily fight to save Matthew from the Advocate, while avoiding a planetwide civil war and a space-and-time misplaced Edwardian Torchwood, still hunting the Doctor since The Time Machination ! Everything leads to this point — but who will die? Complete Completed Favourite Favourited Add Review Edit Review Log a repeat Skip Skipped Unowned Owned Owned Save to my list Saved Edit date completed Custom Date Release Date Archive (no date) Save Characters Tenth Doctor Matthew Finnegan the Advocate Emily Winter Show All Characters (4) Reviews Add Review Edit Review Sort: Default Date (Newest First) Date (Oldest First) Likes (High-Low) Likes (Low-High) Rating (High-Low) Rating (Low-High) Word count (High-Low) Word count (Low-High) Username (A-Z) Username (Z-A) Spoilers First Spoilers Last 1 review 11 February 2025 · 165 words Review by 15thDoctor Spoilers This review contains spoilers! This final chapter in Emily Winter and Matthew Finnegan’s travels with the Doctor is staggeringly ambitious and detail-oriented. Though this IDW run has been relatively brief, these characters have earned my genuine emotional investment. The story isn’t flawless - it concludes with considerable narrative hand-waving, particularly Matthew’s transformation into a mythical catalyst, laden with callbacks to earlier events which don’t feel naturally seeded. Yet the drama remains compelling, delivering a thrilling, fun journey. The Terror Firma / Sol 3 revelation - where communities have evolved into the “terror farmers” and “soul-free” groups - feels overly familiar. The concept of a society regressing from scientific sophistication to primitive detachment, with terms changing over time echoes themes in The Doctor’s Daughter and The Face of Evil. Despite these critiques, the comic is a monumental achievement. The creative team’s ambition shines, particularly in weaving Winter and Finnegan’s arc into the Doctor Who universe. This run of comics - imperfect but bold - leaves me deeply grateful to have experienced it. 15thDoctor View profile Like Liked 0 Open in new window Statistics AVG. Rating230 members 3.64 / 5 Member Statistics Completed 32 Favourited 0 Reviewed 1 Saved 1 Skipped 2 Related Stories Doctor Who Specials The Waters of Mars Rating: 4.45 Story Skipped Television Reviews(17) More Actions View Sets Close Related Sets Set of Stories: Doctor Who 2009 Specials Set of Stories: Doctor Who (2005-2022) Set of Stories: Tenth Doctor Add Review Edit Review Skip Skipped Unowned Owned Save to my list Saved IDW Comics Old Friend Rating: 3.64 Story Skipped Comic Reviews(1) More Actions View Sets Close Related Sets Set of Stories: IDW Comics Set of Stories: Tenth Doctor – IDW Comics Add Review Edit Review Skip Skipped Unowned Owned Save to my list Saved Other adaptations of this story: We define an adaptation as a recreation of a similar story but on a different medium or with different characters. IDW Comics Old Friend Rating: 3.64 Story Skipped Comic Reviews(1) More Actions View Sets Close Related Sets Set of Stories: IDW Comics Set of Stories: Tenth Doctor – IDW Comics Add Review Edit Review Skip Skipped Unowned Owned Save to my list Saved Quotes Add Quote Submit a Quote