Skip to content

Doctor Who: The Tenth Doctor

Echo

3.25/ 5 32 votes

Reviews and links from the Community

Review of Echo by JayPea

Fluff, but solid fluff. I like the way the noise is shown with different styles for the onomatepia, and it’s not something that’d really work in another medium (at least in the same way) which is nice

Review last edited on 15-08-24

Review of Echo by Trench16

Echos: 7.2/10 - This story was pretty good, but not particularly noteworthy in any way. I like Gabby’s reunion with her family which is strangely very short. The Shreekers were a nice funny design that I found amusing and the Echos themselves have a really cool design as well. This story suffers from its short length a lot and leaves a lot to be desired from a “companion returns home” story which is disappointing. Some highlights were the Doctor hanging off the Empire State Building and Gabby driving the moped away from the Shreekers. Also, why did we get no follow up to Cindy after the cold open??!!

Review last edited on 10-06-24

Review of Echo by MrColdStream

🙏🏼58% = Average! = Skippable!

Thworping through time and space, one adventure at a time!

KILLING NOISE!

This shorter story is a palette cleanser that allows us to catch up with Gabby's family (they don't do a lot of catching up, though). Although the art effectively conveys the idea of noise pollution killing people, the overall premise seems more appropriate for TV or Big Finish.

This one is like an action-packed, abridged version of Revolutions of Terror. There's no real time to develop the threat or the characters before it's all over. There's not much substance, but it's a brief, enjoyable read.

The green alien bad guys came and went and reminded me of M.O.D.O.K. from Marvel.

The best aspect of it is how it teaches us to cherish each moment of peace and quiet that comes our way in this hectic and noisy world.

Review last edited on 21-05-24

Review of Echo by ItsR0b0tNinja

Echo is a quick and simple tale that takes place over a single issues. The plot is bare bones, with just enough to get you to the end of the story. This felt more like an outline to Revolutions of Terror than its own story. There really wasn't much substance here. The artwork was clean and pretty. Overall, a nothing story that didn't add much.

Review last edited on 8-05-24

Community Ratings


GoodReads

Votes: 970
Average rating: 4.07 / 5

TARDIS Guide

Votes: 32
Average rating: 3.25 / 5

The Time Scales

Votes: 7
Average rating: 3.45 / 5


(Updates coming soon:)

Add the last X members who rated it here

Add number of Favs, and who they are, here

Ratings are from TARDIS Guide members only.