Skip to content
TARDIS Guide

Back to Story

Reviews

Add Review Edit Review

2 reviews

This review contains spoilers!

This is part of a series of reviews of Doctor Who in chronological timeline order.

Previous Story: The Greatest Show in the Galaxy


This definitely isn't as good as Remembrance of the Daleks but it's nonetheless a solid action thriller. 7 becoming a local politician is quite funny and in line with his character. The Counter Measures team are good fun, this has definitely intrigued me about their spinoff. Aside from Gilmore though I don't think they get much time to shine which is a tad disappointing.

The story is a bit sluggish in the beginning but it really picks up towards the end. It's very exciting which a lot of stories can often fail to be even with absurdly high stakes. It's not exactly like Mission Impossible but that's the best comparison I can think of especially in that last act. The Light feel a bit underbaked though. I think the story on the whole would've worked better without any alien elements at all.

Overall, not the best in the 1963 trilogy but still really strong.


Next Story: Shockwave


thedefinitearticle63

View profile


Primeiro áudio do Pós The Greatest Show In The Galaxy - Temos um thriller político com um toque de ficção científica envolvendo uma conspiração dentro do governo Britânico com direito a vilões que possuem um plano insano de assassinato em massa, e claro uma bomba-relógio. O 7° Doutor como sempre está um pé a frente de todos, deis do início ele já possui o seu plano orquestrado e sob controle.
Infelizmente as intrigas políticas são muito esticadas, ao meu ver não havia necessidade de um aprofundamento tão longo assim, a grande prova disso é seu bloco final (parte 4) onde realiza muito bem uma mescla entre as intrigas políticas e a ação. Antes disso, a história demora 2 partes para construir uma trama e estabelecer os inimigos e os aliados, praticamente são 3 partes de diálogos de problemáticas políticas bem cansativas.
Além disso, fiquei com uma sensação de excesso de personagens, há muitas vozes aqui, muitos personagens dificultando a facilidade em diferenciá-los, o que me ajudou foi o Transcript (porém para aqueles que ouve sem, imagino que esse trabalho seja mais difícil), então já alerto, é necessário um cuidado redobrado no foco e na atenção.
Sinceramente, por mais que seja um BOM áudio (isso não tem como negar), sua temática de "conspiração política" não me atrai muito, ainda mais apresentando um comportamento bem monótono. É um tipo de história que dificilmente eu pegaria para reouvir, mas está longe de ser dispensável.

First audio from The Greatest Show In The Galaxy - We have a political thriller with a touch of science fiction involving a conspiracy within the British government, complete with villains who have an insane mass assassination plan, and of course, a ticking bomb. The 7th Doctor is as always one step ahead of everyone else; from the beginning, he already has his orchestrated plan under control.
Unfortunately, the political intrigues are very drawn out, in my view, there was no need for such lengthy depth. The great proof of this is in its final block (part 4) where it does very well in blending the political intrigues and the action. Before that, the story takes 2 parts to build a plot and establish the enemies and allies, practically 3 parts of very tiring political problematic dialogues.
Moreover, I was left with a sense of too many characters, there are many voices here, many characters making it difficult to distinguish between them, what helped me was the Transcript (however for those who listen without, I imagine this work is more difficult), so I already advise, it requires extra care in focus and attention.
Honestly, although it is a GOOD audio (this cannot be denied), its "political conspiracy" theme does not attract me much, especially as it presents a rather monotonous behavior. It's the type of story I'd hardly pick up to listen to again, but it's far from being negligible.

(Translation generated by AI, so mistakes are possible).


KnuppMello

View profile