Thworping through time and space, one adventure at a time!

ZYGON: WHEN BEING YOU JUST ISN’T ENOUGH – WHEN LOW BUDGET AND ZYGONS JUST AREN’T ENOUGH

A muddled mash of sex, shapeshifting, and pseudo-psychology in Doctor Who’s most notorious spin-off.

Among BBV's grab-bag of low-budget Doctor Who-adjacent spin-offs, Zygon: When Being You Just Isn’t Enough is undoubtedly the most infamous—and not for the reasons anyone might hope. Initially filmed in 2003 but only released in 2008, this so-called “adult” Whoniverse story markets itself as a mature psychological thriller. In reality, it’s an awkward stew of identity confusion, limp sex scenes, uninspired shapeshifting, and baffling attempts at profundity.

On paper, the idea isn’t without promise. A lonely Zygon stranded on Earth, grappling with identity, disconnection, and suppressed memories? That could make for an eerie psychological sci-fi in the right hands. But here, all the interesting ideas are buried beneath a clunky production, a shallow screenplay, and the kind of sexuality that feels like it was written by a teenage boy with a subscription to Heavy Metal magazine.

WHO EVEN ARE YOU, MICHAEL?

Daniel Harcourt stars as Michael Kirkwood, a man plagued by violent dreams, spontaneous shapeshifting, and an all-consuming sense of dissatisfaction. What he doesn’t know—but what the audience quickly realises—is that he’s a dormant Zygon. And not just any Zygon: one with a power-hungry alien ally and a sexually forward therapist (played by Jo Castleton) hovering around him, each with their own barely coherent motivations.

Kirkwood’s “second-in-command” Bob Calhoun (Keith Dinkel, yes, Time-Flight’s Cobie) is actually Torlakh, a murderous Zygon who’s been masquerading as a serial killer for two decades. That idea—what if a notorious killer were secretly a Zygon?—could make for a gripping mystery or a psychological horror. But the film only uses it as a hook for generic manipulation and bland power struggles, not as a launchpad for character or tension.

SEXUALITY, IDENTITY... AND A WHOLE LOT OF SHAPESHIFTING

Zygon clearly wants to be about something: repression, identity, sexuality, even LGBTQA+ coding. There are intriguing hints, such as a sequence where Lauren shapeshifts into a man to sleep with her female colleague—a moment that touches on gender fluidity and repressed desire in a way that could be thoughtful. But like everything else in this film, these ideas are undercooked, surrounded by half-hearted plotting, and ultimately overshadowed by painfully awkward sex scenes.

Rather than exploring anything meaningfully, the movie uses its shape-shifting mechanic as a clumsy narrative crutch. People transform constantly—usually in the middle of an argument or seduction scene—and it quickly becomes impossible to keep track of who’s who. The film seems to forget that mystery and drama require coherence, not just special effects filters and body doubles.

CASTING, CHARACTERISATION, AND THE CRUMBLING PLOT

Jo Castleton does what she can with the role of Lauren, but the script gives her very little to work with. It’s a curious footnote that she once auditioned for the role of Bernice Summerfield—one that went to Lisa Bowerman, who thankfully escaped this project. Keith Dinkel fares a bit better, delivering probably the film’s most convincing performance as the unhinged, manipulative Bob/Torlakh, even if his motivations and personality shift faster than the characters do.

But where things really fall apart is in the third act. What little narrative momentum the film builds grinds to a halt, replaced by scenes that repeat themselves in frustrating loops—confrontation, escape in Bob’s van, rinse, repeat. The climax tries to shift into horror as Lauren’s identity is smeared by a massacre committed by Bob in her likeness, but the tonal whiplash is extreme and the bloodbath feels more B-movie slasher than psychological thriller.

PRODUCTION WOES AND DATED TECHNIQUES

It doesn’t take long to realise this is a deeply low-budget affair. The synth-heavy MIDI soundtrack feels like it wandered in from a CD-ROM game circa 1997. Dream sequences are drenched in cheap filters that try to be surreal but come off as eye-rolling. The direction is static and uninspired, while the dialogue frequently sounds like it was written in the first draft of a student film script.

And yes, there’s nudity—but not nearly as much as the film’s notoriety might suggest. It’s frontloaded, very in-your-face, and almost always awkward. Rather than feeling mature, it’s juvenile—gratuitous without being erotic, supposedly edgy without ever being engaging.

ZYGONS IN NAME ONLY

Doctor Who fans hoping for any kind of continuity or deeper lore will be disappointed. The Zygons here are Zygons only in name, with little attention paid to how the species actually works. The shapeshifting rules are muddled, the biology of creating new Zygons is nonsensical, and even the visual effects (including a very brief appearance of a “real” Zygon at the end) don’t help ground them in recognisable mythology.

And the horror elements? Toothless. The dreams, transformations, and sudden outbursts of violence lack weight or rhythm. What could’ve been eerie ends up ridiculous—especially when the shapeshifting is used purely to disorient the audience rather than build suspense.

📝VERDICT: 4/10

Zygon: When Being You Just Isn’t Enough is a curiosity at best and a chore at worst. It’s a film desperate to be edgy and insightful, but ends up feeling like a muddled, misguided attempt to do The X-Files with a dash of erotic thriller, and none of the competence of either. There are seeds of good ideas—Zygon identity crisis, coded gender fluidity, psychological horror—but they’re all squandered by lazy writing, poor production values, and tonal incoherence.

It’s not entirely unwatchable, and its notoriety alone may make it worth a look for die-hard completists. But for most, this is best left as a bizarre footnote in the extended Doctor Who multiverse.