Skip to content
TARDIS Guide

Review of Warfare by MrColdStream

17 December 2024

This review contains spoilers!

📝10/10

Thworping through time and space, one adventure at a time!

"Warfare: A Grand and Intense Conclusion to Gallifrey's Pandora Arc"

Warfare delivers a thrilling and satisfying climax to the Gallifrey series' ongoing civil war and the Pandora conflict. The stakes have never been higher, and the intricate political manoeuvring, character development, and emotional weight make this story stand out as one of the strongest entries in the series so far.

The narrative dives into themes of identity, sacrifice, and loyalty, particularly with Romana. Her internal conflict over which version of herself she truly is, and the struggle with Pandora sharing her mind, brings some of the series' most gripping and poignant moments. The psychic showdown, where Romana sacrifices herself to allow Pandora to manifest and ultimately defeat her by surrendering her to the Sentience in the Matrix, is a powerful, well-earned conclusion. Lalla Ward's and Mary Tamm's performances shine, especially in sequences where they seamlessly juggle between Pandora's cunning malevolence and Romana's strength and vulnerability.

Leela, even while blinded, remains a fierce warrior and a brilliant strategist. Her leadership in the battles on the war's fringes demonstrates her ability to adapt and inspire others. Louise Jameson's performance adds so much raw intensity to her character—she’s a fighter through and through, yet there's a tender bond with Romana that provides grounding emotional stakes.

Narvin, ever loyal to Gallifrey despite his personal conflicts with Romana, brings a strong strategic presence. His desperate plan to destroy the Matrix highlights the gravity of the situation, and his animosity toward Darkel adds layers of tension and intrigue. Their ongoing verbal clashes, as Narvin refuses to be manipulated, are a standout part of the narrative. Darkel's cunning move to weaponize the Free Time virus is a brilliant and ruthless tactic, proving her continued presence as a formidable political player.

The supporting cast is given significant moments to shine, with characters like Lord Matthias and Commander Hallan gaining greater depth. Matthias’ duplicity and final gambit alongside Pandora create a formidable threat, while Hallan’s infection with the virus leads to one of the story’s tensest sequences.

The sound design and score elevate the intensity, effectively immersing the listener in Gallifrey's war-torn chaos. The depiction of the battles—audibly grand and devastating—feels more epic than anything heard in the series before. It’s complemented by smaller, character-driven clashes that showcase the personal toll of the conflict.

K9 faking his alliance with Pandora while remaining loyal to Romana is a clever and satisfying twist. It’s these smaller moments that give the story depth amidst the larger battles.

The final act of Warfare is where everything comes together beautifully. Romana’s desperate dive into the Matrix to restore Leela’s sight and confront her earlier self feels like the culmination of her emotional and psychological journey. The release of the dogma virus to destroy the Matrix and Pandora is an intense, climactic resolution that perfectly balances action and character stakes.

The story closes on a note of exhaustion and triumph, with Romana collapsing under the sheer weight of the decisions and sacrifices she's made. It’s a fitting ending that highlights her immense resilience while acknowledging the toll of leadership and war.

Warfare delivers a spectacular, intense, and satisfying conclusion to the Pandora arc. The story balances political intrigue, emotional stakes, and large-scale conflict while staying true to the characters we've grown to love. Romana's internal struggles, Leela's warrior spirit, and Narvin’s tactical brilliance make this a rich, rewarding listen. With stellar performances, intricate plotting, and epic sound design, this story is a standout entry that brings the civil war to a dramatic and emotional close—while leaving tantalizing threads for future chapters.

This is Gallifrey at its best.