Skip to content
TARDIS Guide

Review of The War Games by MrColdStream

29 December 2024

This review contains spoilers!

Thworping through time and space, one adventure at a time!

“The War Games: A Monumental and Influential Classic”

The War Games is an epic tale that epitomises everything remarkable about Patrick Troughton’s tenure as the Doctor while also serving as a grand send-off to his era. Despite its ten-episode length and occasional padding, the story remains a masterpiece of tension, innovation, and characterisation, setting the stage for much of the lore that defines Doctor Who today.

The genius of The War Games lies in its ability to transform a seemingly simple narrative into a rich, multi-layered epic. Beginning as a war drama set in the trenches of World War I, the story gradually evolves into a high-stakes science fiction thriller. The introduction of armies from different historical periods, manipulated to fight endless wars on a single alien planet, is a brilliantly original concept.

This juxtaposition of historical and futuristic elements creates an engaging dynamic that keeps the story fresh throughout its runtime. The plot twists and revelations—from the true nature of the War Chief to the Time Lords’ role—ensure that the stakes grow continuously until the explosive finale.

Patrick Troughton delivers one of his finest performances as the Second Doctor. His blend of cunning, humour, and moral conviction shines through, particularly in the final episodes. The courtroom scenes, where he passionately defends his actions, are a standout, showcasing the depth and range of his Doctor.

Frazer Hines (Jamie) and Wendy Padbury (Zoe) are equally exceptional, proving why this TARDIS team is a fan favourite. Their camaraderie and determination come to the forefront as they lead the resistance, offering many memorable moments. Their emotional departure, forced by the Time Lords, is one of the most poignant farewells in the series’ history.

The supporting cast is stellar. Philip Madoc’s War Lord is a cold, calculating villain, and Edward Brayshaw’s War Chief is an enigmatic and charismatic presence. Their scenes together crackle with tension, particularly as their motives and loyalties come into conflict. Jane Sherwin as Lady Jennifer adds a welcome layer of strength and independence, while Noel Coleman’s General Smythe exudes menace.

The introduction of the Time Lords is one of the story’s most significant contributions to Doctor Who lore. Their portrayal as an omnipotent yet morally ambiguous race adds depth to the Doctor’s character, especially as he struggles with his decision to call on them for help. The War Chief’s connection to the Doctor hints at the rich backstory of Gallifrey, further explored in later years.

The story’s exploration of war, control, and resistance gives it an enduring relevance. Its depiction of moral dilemmas, particularly the Doctor’s inability to save the day alone, elevates it beyond a typical adventure.

David Maloney’s direction is exemplary, managing to keep this lengthy serial visually engaging. The World War I sequences feel authentic, and the alien command centre is suitably eerie. The use of location filming adds a cinematic quality, and the haunting music score enhances the atmosphere of tension and unease.

While the ten-episode structure does lead to some repetitive moments—such as the Doctor and companions being captured and escaping multiple times—the variety of settings and characters ensures the story remains engaging.

The War Games is one of the most influential stories in Doctor Who history. It introduced concepts and characters that continue to shape the series, from the Time Lords to the Doctor’s moral dilemmas. The epic scale and layered storytelling make it a fitting finale for the Second Doctor’s era.

📝Verdict: 9/10

Though its length may be daunting, The War Games is a richly rewarding experience. It’s a perfect blend of drama, action, and characterisation, featuring one of the most emotionally charged finales in Doctor Who. A cornerstone of the show’s legacy, it remains a must-watch for fans of the classic series.

Random Observations:

  • The German soldier in episode 3 is so amazingly over-the-top I can't help but love him. His reaction to the sonic screwdriver is priceless.
  • Is it just me, or does the German general look like Blofeld from You Only Live Twice?
  • So many things with this story remind me of Westworld.
  • I love the War Scientist, who is so devoted to his work that it takes a better part of two episodes for him to realise The Doctor isn't who he claims he is.
  • There it is, the first time the Time Lords are mentioned by name, at the start of Episode 6. Interestingly, not by the Doctor or the War Chief, but by the Scientist.
  • The scene in Episode 7 where Carstairs struggles to speak French with the rescued soldier is intentionally hilarious. The TARDIS should, of course, translate everything for everyone, but this serial seems to use that logic pretty loosely whenever the script requires that.
  • There have never been enough great Mexican characters on the show, so we're lucky that the Troughton era gave us two: Salamander in The Enemy of the World and the loveably trigger-happy Pancho Villa here.
  • The Episode 9 cliffhanger is arguably the most intense and dramatic since the ending to The Daleks' Master Plan.