The Sirens of Time isn’t the strongest start to Big Finish’s Doctor Who journey… but it is a fascinating one. You can feel the ambition straight away: three different Doctors, each in their own mini-adventure, coming together for a big finale. But while that structure sounds exciting, in practice it’s a bit wobbly. The individual segments don’t quite gel, and by the time we get to the final act, it feels like it’s sprinting to tie everything up. It’s a bit like watching three Part Ones followed by a slightly confused Part Four.

That said, there’s loads to enjoy along the way. Davison’s U-boat thriller is genuinely atmospheric, and Colin Baker’s space-conference escapade is a surprisingly great showcase for his Doctor, full of personality and presence. McCoy’s section doesn’t quite hit the same heights, but it’s not without its charm. The real secret weapon here is the supporting cast: Maggie Stables is deliciously unhinged, and Sarah Mowat gives a brilliantly layered performance that hints at how good Big Finish’s casting choices would become.

So, no, it’s not perfect. But I still love what it represents. It’s Big Finish taking its first steps, figuring out what works and what doesn’t, and laying the groundwork for 20+ years of storytelling brilliance. You probably wouldn’t start here if you’re new to the audios, but as a piece of Who history? It’s essential listening. Wobbly, ambitious, and kind of wonderful.