Skip to content
TARDIS Guide

Review of The Romans by MrColdStream

12 August 2024

This review contains spoilers!

📝10/10

Thworping through time and space, one adventure at a time!

"The Romans: A Witty Romp Through Nero’s Court"

The Romans is a delightful blend of comedy and historical adventure set during the reign of Emperor Nero. Dennis Spooner delivers one of his best scripts, combining humor, drama, and clever storytelling into a serial that's as entertaining as it is unique.

The story opens on an unexpected note, with the TARDIS crew enjoying a rare moment of peace, relaxing just outside Rome as though on holiday. This lighthearted beginning sets the tone for a production filled with lively sets, stunning costumes, and evocative period music that enrich the experience.

The chemistry among the leads is a highlight, with Ian and Barbara's undeniable romantic spark shining through, and Barbara and Vicki’s camaraderie adding warmth. The three intertwined storylines—a mistaken identity leading the Doctor to Nero’s court, Barbara and Ian’s misadventures as slaves, and their eventual near-reunion—are masterfully woven together. The characters’ independent escapades, often narrowly missing each other, create a charming narrative device that enhances the comedic undertones.

William Hartnell gives one of his best performances as the Doctor, showcasing his comedic timing and quick wit. His portrayal balances the Doctor’s grandfatherly warmth with his mischievous delight in witnessing (and occasionally influencing) history. His encounters with Nero, especially the lyre ruse and his accidental role in the Great Fire of Rome, are standout moments.

The serial also excels in balancing dramatic tension with humor. Ian’s stint as a gladiator and the galley slave sequence are gritty and realistic, while the absurdity of Nero’s antics and Barbara’s attempts to evade him provide plenty of laughs. Derek Francis steals the show as the hilariously self-absorbed Nero, offering one of the series’ most memorable depictions of a historical figure. Anne Tirard’s eerie Locusta and Michael Peake’s morally ambiguous Tavius further enrich the guest cast.

The script avoids repetitive tropes, maintaining a brisk pace. The gladiator fight and the thrilling climax, where the Doctor inadvertently sets the Great Fire of Rome in motion, are among the serial’s most memorable moments. It’s a clever nod to the show’s evolving approach to history, subtly moving beyond the strict "history is immutable" stance of The Aztecs.

With its sharp wit, strong performances, and engaging narrative, The Romans is a shining example of Doctor Who at its finest—a delightful fusion of history, comedy, and adventure.