Review of The Reaping by thedefinitearticle63
18 October 2024
This review contains spoilers
Previous Story: Cryptobiosis
This is probably one of the realest feeling audios out there, along with The Gathering. To clarify, it presents life in the most unglamourised way possible. It has a very somber atmosphere, with Peri finding out about a family friend's death and rushing back to visit their funeral. Like The Gathering, it really explores the life without/after the Doctor. It strips back the fairy-tale like adventures of Doctor Who and takes us back to the real world.
I'm gonna say, I don't think this story would be nearly as effective without Nicola Bryant's FANTASTIC performance. Not only is she really having to pull her weight alongside actual American actors (a testament to how good her American accent is when it blends into the story seamlessly), she's putting in one of the best performances I've seen a companion actor do as Peri is put through the wringer in this story.
While the Doctor is a bit more of a side character here, that doesn't stop Colin Baker from putting in a similarly great performance. The scene where he comforts Peri at the end stood out to me specifically. As for the Cybermen in this story, I think they're very unique here. They're cunning and crafty in a way that regular Cybermen usually aren't and it's fun to listen to.
I think the only thing I disliked in this story was how abrupt and ridiculous Peri's mum's death was. I don't mind her death as a plot point, but blowing up because of a Cyberman gadget the Doctor left behind is a bit stupid. Otherwise, it's a fantastic audio and a really great story for Peri as a character in particular.
Next Story: Recorded Time