Thworping through time and space, one adventure at a time!

"THE MERFOLK MURDERS: A TIMELESS WHODUNIT WITH A SCI-FI TWIST"

Set in 1940s Scotland, The Merfolk Murders sees the Fifth Doctor, Nyssa, Tegan, and Adric entangled in a real-life murder mystery amidst a university society dedicated to crime fiction. What starts as a discussion of detective novels—specifically the Orion Hood series, inspired by none other than the Fourth Doctor and penned by Sarah Jane Smith—soon spirals into an intricate web of intrigue, espionage, and deception. While the wartime setting feels somewhat underdeveloped, the story thrives as a Doctor Who take on a classic whodunit.

A STEADY BUILD-UP WITH A LACK OF TENSION

The opening episode takes its time establishing the mystery and its players, though it struggles to evoke the weight of the World War II backdrop. Despite elements like a German spy subplot, there’s a noticeable lack of tension throughout much of the serial. However, for those who enjoy a traditional murder mystery, the structured storytelling—with red herrings and clues sprinkled throughout—makes for an engaging listen. The final episode, in particular, delivers a satisfying Poirot-style resolution, neatly tying up the various plot threads.

STRONG CHARACTERISATION AND COMPANION DYNAMICS

The TARDIS team is well-served here, with Nyssa and Adric’s alien perspectives standing out, while Tegan provides a grounded, no-nonsense counterpoint. Their interactions, filled with sharp dialogue and differing viewpoints, prove to be one of the highlights of the story. The guest cast is also given plenty to do, ensuring that each suspect feels distinct and involved in the unfolding mystery.

A UNIQUE AND AMUSING EPILOGUE

One of the more refreshing aspects of The Merfolk Murders is its extended conclusion, which jumps forward in time to explore the long-term impact of the mystery’s resolution on those involved. This rare glimpse beyond the immediate aftermath of a historical adventure is both effective and humorous, providing a fittingly light-hearted end to an otherwise methodical mystery.

VERDICT: A CLASSIC MURDER MYSTERY IN WARTIME SCOTLAND

A rare pure historical for the Fifth Doctor era, The Merfolk Murders embraces its murder mystery roots with an engaging whodunit structure and strong character moments. While the story lacks sustained tension and doesn’t fully capitalise on its wartime setting, its intricate plotting and compelling resolution make it a rewarding listen for fans of detective fiction.

📝6/10