Thworping through time and space, one adventure at a time!

“The Invention of Death: A Philosophical Journey Through Alien Emotion”

John Dorney’s The Invention of Death, the opening story of the second volume of The First Doctor Adventures, takes listeners on a deeply philosophical journey. The story masterfully balances a richly detailed alien world with mature explorations of human emotions and mortality, creating a compelling blend of classic Doctor Who storytelling and thought-provoking drama.

The TARDIS Team in Their Element

By this point, the new cast of The First Doctor Adventures has fully settled into their roles. David Bradley's portrayal of the First Doctor is appropriately protective and stern, especially in his interactions with Susan, who is wonderfully quick-witted and curious. Ian and Barbara continue to provide a grounding human perspective, and their bond is explored subtly but meaningfully—especially when an alien society inadvertently reveals Ian’s feelings for Barbara.

The opening TARDIS scene is a highlight, establishing the team dynamic with warmth and humour. The singing scene in Part Two—a rare moment of pure levity—offers a delightful respite and encapsulates the charm of this audio series.

The Ashtallahn Society: A Triumph of World-Building

The planet Ashtallah and its inhabitants are among the most fascinating creations in Big Finish’s history. The Ashtallahns, an alien species unfamiliar with concepts like love, fear, and death, provide a mirror through which the story examines fundamental aspects of humanity. Their unique perspective allows for poignant discussions between the TARDIS crew and the Ashtallahns, touching on topics such as heartbreak and mortality.

The alien world is vividly brought to life through the dialogue and sound design, creating an atmosphere reminiscent of the ambitious surrealism of The Web Planet but with greater narrative focus and clarity.

From Philosophy to Mystery

The story takes a darker turn in Part Two, as the Ashtallahn society begins to unravel when human emotions and fears spread like a virus. The first murder on Ashtallah raises the stakes, and the narrative shifts into a gripping mystery. The investigation is as much about uncovering the truth as it is about grappling with the unintended consequences of human influence on an alien culture.

Themes of Love, Fear, and Mortality

Dorney’s script excels at weaving philosophical debate into the narrative without sacrificing momentum. The Ashtallahns’ innocent yet profound questions about love and death allow the TARDIS crew to reflect on what it means to be human. These moments of introspection feel authentic to the Hartnell era, with its penchant for exploring big ideas through intimate character moments.

📝87/100

The Invention of Death is a top-tier adventure that pairs its richly imagined alien setting with a deeply human story. By blending thoughtful debate, emotional resonance, and a compelling mystery, it captures the spirit of the First Doctor’s era while offering something entirely new.