Skip to content
TARDIS Guide

Review of The Five O’Clock Shadow by hallieday

7 November 2024

This review contains spoilers!

The First Doctor #7

'The Five O'Clock Shadow' (2005) from Short Trips: A Day in the Life.


Quite an irritating little poem - not much of a fan of the way that it's written, nor of the storybook villain that has no visual descriptors and its only other description is a bunch of vague themes. I was hoping that The Five O'Clock Shadow would be in some way related to the man that Susan saw in the mirror in The Exiles but alas it seems not to be. I suppose the inclusion of the Peter Cushing Doctor and Susan is a fair way to attempt to draw them into the First Doctor's canonical timeline, but in a one-note and too brief story that doesn't do much else for me it feels like a bit of a wasted concept.