Review of The Day of the Doctor by 15thDoctor
19 November 2024
They pulled it off. The most incredible magic trick where everyone got what they wanted. Whether you have only watched a couple of Doctor Who episodes or have seen it all, you will feel something watching this. It isn’t just an anniversary episode. It is a robust, coherent story that is both fitting and one of the best bits of writing the show has ever seen.
If it is a runaround. If it is a runaround. It is the best runaround in the show’s history. It is not just content in celebrating The Doctor’s past, but also creates a new past, all while wrapping up the first 8 years of New Who.
It feels like this level of quality comes from nowhere because the series that proceeds it is so disjointed. This story makes me hopeful about the show’s future, and grateful for what we already have as fans. It is a major milestone, following the first 50 years, which makes me wish I could sit down with Verity Lambert, or Terry Nation, or Robert Holmes, or any of the many people involved in building this incredible show, and show them The Day of the Doctor. Show them the product of their vision and all of the parts of them that are within it.
John Hurt, David Tennent and Matt Smith are phenomenal. The supporting cast around them knock it out of the park. There is no doubt that this is the show at the peak of its popularity and these talented people are lapping that energy up and making beautiful, populist television out of it. Television that feels like a monumental movie. An anniversary episode that makes me proud to be a fan.
And it’s not even just The Day of the Doctor itself. It’s The Night of the Doctor; An Adventure in Space and Time; The Five(ish) Doctors; even the bloody Aftershow. All of that makes for the most overwhelmingly joyful 50th anniversary celebration. It was the most beautiful time to be a Doctor Who fan.