Search & filter every Whoniverse story ever made!
View stories featuring your favourite characters & track your progress!
Complete sets of stories, track them on the homepage, earn badges!
Join TARDIS Guide to keep track of the stories you've completed - rate them, add to favourites, get stats!
Lots more Guides are on their way!
3 June 2025
This review contains spoilers!
I absolutely loved the first part of this story, and then it fell flat in part two.
This story dared to go in a totally different direction with the pair, and suggest that, while on the surface, they are good friends, they keep secrets from each other and are in a more dysfunctional relationship - the Doctor is suggested to be darker and hypocritical, and pushes Leela over the edge - and then part two just forgets all that and they just work as a team to beat the monsters. Louise's Fourth Doctor impression was a little lacking too, as she says herself in the interviews.
H'mbreckle was an interesting character, essentially being a reflection of Leela, and something that works for the Companion Chronicles is how the audience hears the story from the companion's perspective, so it's interesting how Leela sees herself in the Z'Nai, and how she is manipulated by the imprisoned creature to turn on the Doctor - really compelling stuff. Also, it was a super dark cliffhanger - killing a child! Was not expecting that, especially for Big Finish. However, part 2 comes along and more Z'Nai come and they turn into generic monster which are defeated so quickly that we don't have time to realise what's happened.
It seems we're sticking with the Edwardian theme from the Chimes of Midnight - unfortunately, this feels very confined, and we don't really get to delve deep into this atmosphere, just being a dining room and a trophy room basically.
There was some interesting ideas with the Doctor having once travelled with someone else that we never knew - Joshua Douglas. The change of this character seen from his daughter's eyes really adds to the tension that's built up in the first part (and dropped in the second) between the Doctor and Leela, showing an outward perspective of what the Doctor does to people.
Overall, I had some high hopes for this story - Episode One is one of the best episodes I've ever heard, and then Episode Two is one of the biggest disappointing conclusions to a good story. I don't even get the ending - how did Leela get captured by the Z'Nai? Why was she being tortured? Did she die? Did she become one of them? I don't understand. Such a shame.
Ryebean
View profile
Not a member? Join for free! Forgot password?
Content