Thworping through time and space, one adventure at a time!

"Storm Warning: The Return of the Eighth Doctor"

Storm Warning is a landmark release for Big Finish, marking the triumphant return of Paul McGann as the Eighth Doctor after his sole on-screen appearance in the 1996 TV Movie. As his first foray into audio drama, this story lays the foundation for what would become a defining era for his Doctor, blending character-driven drama, thrilling action, and hints of a grander narrative arc.

The opening scene immediately reintroduces McGann with energy and flair, plunging listeners into an exciting and dynamic sequence. McGann’s vibrant and passionate performance reminds us of his potential as an action-hero Doctor, fully embracing his character’s youthful charisma and adventurous spirit. His chemistry with India Fisher’s Charlotte Pollard (introduced here as Charley) is undeniable, with their quick rapport and mutual wit setting the tone for a compelling Doctor-companion duo.

Charley is more than a standard companion, introduced as a spirited Edwardian adventuress with a knack for getting into trouble. Her storyline as an anomaly in time adds a fascinating layer of complexity, hinting at larger consequences to come and prefiguring similar ideas later seen in the revived series.

The setting—a royal airship navigating treacherous skies in the 1930s—provides a richly atmospheric backdrop. The sound design is immersive, from the creaking hull of the airship to the howling storm outside, effectively pulling listeners into the tense and mysterious journey.

The guest cast adds depth to the story. Barnaby Edwards is a standout as Rathbone, while Hylton Collins, Gareth Thomas, and Helen Goldwyn bring their characters to life with memorable performances. Goldwyn’s portrayal of a larger-than-life alien voice also sets a precedent for Big Finish’s penchant for imaginative extraterrestrials.

The plot unfolds in classic Doctor Who fashion, with a blend of historical intrigue and high-concept science fiction. The Vortisaurs are an inventive addition, providing both tension and an exhilarating action set piece as the Doctor rides one through the storm. The climactic crash sequence is particularly cinematic, showcasing Big Finish’s ability to deliver high-stakes drama even without visuals.

However, the story isn’t without flaws. The early sections suffer from overly expository dialogue, with characters frequently narrating their actions and surroundings. This clunky writing can occasionally pull listeners out of the experience. Additionally, Part 3 drags slightly, feeling overstretched compared to the tighter pacing of the other episodes. The high-concept sci-fi elements in the latter half may also prove challenging to follow for some listeners.

📝Verdict: 8/10

Despite these minor issues, Storm Warning is a strong debut for the Eighth Doctor’s audio adventures. It reestablishes McGann’s Doctor with charm and energy, introduces a beloved companion, and sets the stage for a new era of Doctor Who. For fans of McGann or those looking to explore Big Finish’s take on the Doctor, this is an essential listen.