Skip to content
TARDIS Guide

Review of Silence in the Library by Jann

27 May 2025

New Who Review #50


Silence In The Library


This story was really good. I haven't really been enjoying series 4 up until this point but this episode was so good. The whole premise of 4022 people going missing even though they were saved but they didn't survive is creepy. Its a very confusing story but when you get your head round it it's so good. There's the whole other story with River Song and who she is. At the time I assume this was pretty exciting. Having a big character and not knowing who she is and having to wait just like the doctor to find out. There's a reason River is so loved and its because she's a very very good character.  This story is actually really scary and I love it. This era hasn't really been scary up to now and it's felt more family friendly but this story changes that. It's so dark and weird that I can't help but love it. Overall amazing story and episode. 10/10


Jann

View profile