Search & filter every Whoniverse story ever made!
View stories featuring your favourite characters & track your progress!
Complete sets of stories, track them on the homepage, earn badges!
Join TARDIS Guide to keep track of the stories you've completed - rate them, add to favourites, get stats!
Lots more Guides are on their way!
16 January 2025
This review contains spoilers!
Thworping through time and space, one adventure at a time!
"Ruby Red: A Frozen Adventure of Aliens, History, and Heroics"
Ruby Red begins with a brisk, engaging pace that immediately feels like a quintessential Doctor Who cold open. The frosty Estonian setting, reminiscent of The Deviant Strain, transports us to a fresh locale in medieval times—a far cry from the usual futuristic or urban landscapes.
The historical backdrop of the Battle on the Ice between the Duchy of Estonia and the Republic of Novgorod is a fascinating choice. It’s always a treat when Doctor Who highlights lesser-known historical events, and this one is both visually evocative and thematically rich.
Characters that Shine
The Doctor and Ruby are well-realised in this story, though the Doctor feels slightly fuzzier around the edges compared to their TV counterpart. Ruby, however, is spot-on, capturing her TV personality with precision.
Ran, the alien mercenary on a rite of passage, is a standout. Her proactive nature and quick bond with the TARDIS team make her an engaging addition. The introduction of her Rentaran sisters brings some intrigue, though their presence feels more like a standard narrative detour than a fully fleshed-out subplot.
Pacing and Structure
The first half of the story mirrors the rapid pacing of a New Who episode, delivering a relentless barrage of action, danger, and alien mystery. These chapters are exhilarating but leave little room for deeper exploration of the historical setting.
The middle chapters slow down, offering backstory and character moments that feel serviceable but not groundbreaking. While these sections maintain interest, they lean into formulaic storytelling rather than pushing boundaries.
Action and Atmosphere
The latter half ramps up the action, blending elements of The Deviant Strain, Last Christmas, and Alien. The alien parasites and zombie hosts provide a creepy and chaotic foe, with the tension building to a nail-biting climax on the frozen lake.
Cook’s action writing is a highlight, capturing the peril and excitement with cinematic flair. The sequence on the lake is particularly thrilling, with icy dangers and high stakes that keep you on edge.
Missed Opportunities
While the historical setting is beautifully atmospheric, it feels underutilised in terms of plot. The Battle on the Ice and its cultural significance are overshadowed by the alien conflict, leaving the setting as more of a backdrop than an integral element of the story.
A Satisfying Conclusion
The climax is satisfying, with Ran’s heroic moment and the Doctor’s tense encounter with Genetrix inside the TARDIS providing strong payoffs. The narrative wisely takes time to wrap up its loose ends, giving the story a more rounded and complete feel.
The Verdict: A Chilling but Familiar Adventure
Ruby Red delivers a well-structured, action-packed adventure that captures the energy of a New Who episode. Its unique setting and intriguing characters shine, though the story occasionally feels constrained by its adherence to familiar Doctor Who tropes.
For fans of historical adventures and alien intrigue, this is a solid and enjoyable read, even if it doesn’t fully capitalise on its promising setup.
📝70/100
Not a member? Join for free! Forgot password?
Content