Skip to content
TARDIS Guide

Review of Project: Twilight by thedefinitearticle63

1 November 2024

This review contains spoilers!

This is part of a series of reviews of Doctor Who in chronological timeline order.

Previous Story: Bloodtide


Wow, that was awful. This story is like if you melted down all the worst parts of season 22 and concentrated it into one painfully terrible adventure. It's so edgy and gratuitously violent for no real reason. I didn't need to hear a man explode and then all the blood and organs splatter on the walls and floor. And I definitely didn't need to hear it a SECOND time. I hate how badly characterised the Doctor is here, he's so stupid. He trusts the mysterious people running the shady casino who don't flinch when a man explodes in front of them for literally no reason and then gets shocked when they turn out to be evil. He puts Evelyn in needless danger and even gets tricked into making a super-virus for the vampires. This story likes to pull a lot of things out of nowhere, like the aforementioned super-virus or when a character gets attacked and then says "did I forget to mention my armour?" as a lazy way of explaining why nothing happened to him.

While I really like Maggie Stables so far as Evelyn, she was downright insufferable in this story. No fault of her performance, but rather the writing. Like the Doctor, she made a lot of out-of-character decisions like leaving Cassie with someone who was clearly going to torture her. That whole sequence was ridiculous because the Doctor told Evelyn to stay with Cassie only for Evelyn to believe a lie that the Doctor "needed her to fetch something". It was a pointless decision made just so the writers could shove in some torture scenes. This story manages to make the 2 hour long snoozefest that is The Apocalypse Element seem like a short trip, and this is half an hour shorter. It's a shame because I genuinely enjoyed the atmosphere at the start and the soundtrack was phenomenal.

Overall, this is an exceedingly dull and needlessly gory story. I understand that this is the start of a very important and expansive arc in the Main Range so if the rest of those stories are anything like this I'm going to have a hard time.


Next Story: The Maltese Penguin