Skip to content
TARDIS Guide

Review of Project: Twilight by MrColdStream

20 December 2024

This review contains spoilers!

Thworping through time and space, one adventure at a time!

"Project: Twilight – A Dark, Eerie Thriller with Rich Performances"

Project: Twilight weaves an eerie and sinister tale right from the start, immersing the audience in its unsettling world as the Doctor and Evelyn Smythe stumble into a web of mystery and danger. The story begins with tantalizing glimpses of horrifying acts and sinister characters, creating an unsettling atmosphere that tightens as the narrative progresses.

The grim setting, laced with dead bodies, blood, and macabre details, immediately sets the tone. The sound design and evocative music amplify the tension, perfectly complementing the stellar performances. Colin Baker’s portrayal of the Sixth Doctor is as commanding as ever, while Maggie Stables shines as Evelyn, whose moral grounding and sharp wit create a compelling contrast to the dark events around them.

The story’s atmosphere remains deeply uneasy throughout, with sinister undertones that keep the listener on edge. Nimrod, voiced chillingly by Stephen Chance, emerges as a standout villain. His cold, calculating nature and haunting voice linger long after his scenes, while Rob Dixon’s Reggie is equally detestable, played with a menacing edge that makes his every action discomforting.

Project: Twilight takes a fresh spin on the vampire mythos, delivering a Doctor Who twist that feels both inventive and unsettling. The introduction of the Forge and its enigmatic lore adds depth to the narrative, laying the groundwork for future stories while keeping the current plot engaging.

The cliffhanger at the end of Part 2 is a standout moment, with Nimrod’s chilling reveal sending shivers down the spine. The Doctor’s shock at encountering vampires—despised by Time Lords—is a highlight, as is his fraught dynamic with Evelyn, who challenges him on ethical and moral grounds.

As the story progresses, the darkness deepens, with Part 3 delivering an unexpected and grim twist that forces the Doctor to confront the consequences of his actions. Some of the imagery is strikingly grotesque—so much so that it would likely never make it to television—adding a visceral edge to the narrative.

However, the plot becomes somewhat convoluted in Part 4, where the intricate threads of the story threaten to overwhelm the pacing. The conclusion, while serviceable, feels abrupt and slightly unsatisfying, leaving a few loose ends dangling.

📝Verdict: 8/10

Project: Twilight is a haunting and atmospheric story elevated by its performances, music, and sound design. Despite a slightly rushed ending, it introduces compelling lore and memorable villains, making it a standout entry in the Sixth Doctor’s audio adventures.