Thworping through time and space, one adventure at a time! 

“Master: A Haunting Reflection on Good, Evil, and Redemption”

The final part of Big Finish's Villains Trilogy is a compelling exploration of morality, identity, and the complex relationship between the Doctor and the Master. Framed as a haunted house mystery, the Seventh Doctor faces off against the decayed incarnation of the Master (voiced by Geoffrey Beevers), who exists under the persona of "John Smith." This character-driven story delivers an eerie, atmospheric tale packed with psychological tension, ethical dilemmas, and standout performances.

Atmosphere and Setting: A Classic Gothic Tale

The story’s intimate setting—a remote house shrouded in stormy weather—immediately establishes a brooding atmosphere. The unsettling sound design, with strange voices echoing through the halls, enhances the story's haunted quality. The anonymity of the house's owner, Doctor John Smith, and the gradually revealed secrets of the supporting characters sustain a constant undercurrent of unease.

The classic Gothic overtones—hidden identities, dark pasts, and the thin line between good and evil—make this a standout example of Big Finish's ability to reimagine Doctor Who in new and evocative ways.

The Master Reimagined: A Tragic and Unstable Figure

Geoffrey Beevers delivers a masterful performance as the decayed Master, torn between his John Smith persona and the dark memories of his true identity. The parallels to Doctor Jekyll and Mr. Hyde are clear as Smith's outward civility crumbles under the weight of his suppressed nature. His interactions with the Doctor are electrifying, particularly as the story probes whether redemption is possible for someone as corrupted as the Master.

The supporting cast amplifies the Master’s complexity. Jacqueline, played by Anne Ridler (from Wheel in Space), represents a misguided hope for the Master’s redemption, believing in the goodness of his John Smith persona. Meanwhile, Philip Madoc’s (one of the all-time great Doctor Who guest stars; see The War Games and The Brain of Morbius) Victor steals the show in Part 4, his transformation from a seemingly helpful friend to a brutal murderer adding layers of moral ambiguity to the tale. This is easily Madoc’s finest performance in the Whoniverse.

The Seventh Doctor: Manipulative and Unpredictable

Sylvester McCoy’s Seventh Doctor is at his most enigmatic and manipulative here, entering the narrative as a delirious stranger and slowly unraveling the mysteries of the house. His morally ambiguous deal with Death and his willingness to exploit others to entrap the Master highlight the darker side of this incarnation. The Doctor’s conversations with the Master about evil, responsibility, and their shared past are some of the story’s most gripping moments.

Themes of Love, Betrayal, and Death

This story delves deeply into the Doctor and Master’s shared history, suggesting that the Doctor once committed murder to protect his childhood friend. This revelation recontextualises their relationship, presenting it as a tragic tale of betrayal and lost potential.

The introduction of Death, played with chilling authority by Charlie Hayes, adds an existential weight to the narrative. Her offer to free the Master from his torment—or to trap the Doctor in her service—creates a harrowing moral dilemma. The story’s exploration of love and redemption as potential avenues for the Master to escape his darkness is poignant, though ultimately unresolved.

A Gripping Climax

The final part brings the tension to a boil. The reveal of Death's manipulation, the unraveling of Victor’s murders, and the Doctor’s ultimate betrayal of the Master create a crescendo of drama. The Master’s decision, left ambiguous until the very end, keeps the listener on edge. The story concludes with the Doctor facing Death's punishment, a haunting and fitting end for such a morally complex tale.

📝Verdict: 98/100

Master is a standout entry in the Villains Trilogy, blending Gothic horror, psychological depth, and philosophical inquiry. Its exploration of the Doctor and Master’s shared history, combined with strong performances and a tense, atmospheric setting, make it a must-listen for fans of darker, character-driven Doctor Who stories.