Search & filter every Whoniverse story ever made!
View stories featuring your favourite characters & track your progress!
Complete sets of stories, track them on the homepage, earn badges!
Join TARDIS Guide to keep track of the stories you've completed - rate them, add to favourites, get stats!
Lots more Guides are on their way!
18 April 2025
This review contains spoilers!
WE’RE FREE! I’M FREE! THE ART IS ACTUALLY READABLE! HURRAY! HUZZAH! sorry. This isn’t about the weeping angels anymore. I know. wont happen again no yes o7
Ah, you know what, let’s start with the art again. Art, not perfect, but SUCH a breeze after last story. I don’t think the balance between cartoony and realistic is struck completely rightly, but that’s a matter of taste. Some panel structuring I thought was unnecessarily overdone and bordering on confusing, but maybe I’m just stupid, so who cares, really. The characters aren’t as fluid or dynamic as I think they could be, but it’s not bad at all, and there’s a real sense of danger and scale conveyed in the panels, especially with the onomatopoeia. Because oh my god, that, that, is so incredibly cool. So amazingly done. The way the sound literally visually overwhelms the reader is masterfully pulled off. Like I genuinely feel noise overstimulation in a comic book. The way it can go from a background element into getting a bit of a noticeable emphasis, to becoming obscuring for the reader, and how that’s used in making us feel trapped with the characters, goshhhh it’s just so brilliant. I love it so much. It’s so awesome, and I really think a concept like this, with such great execution in the visual department is deserving of exploration and experimentation in a larger story with more plot.
Because so far, I don’t think I like Morrison as a comic book writer. Because simply said, this story has almost no plot. There is danger, running to place, problem solved with magic. So you think Okay. Then we’re going to get to see stuff for our characters. Gabby is back home, lets see how the last few (currently two, but knowing Doctor Who writers, in a few years time we’ll have extra adventures slotted in there, hear you me. I hope at least, in my opinion that’d be awesome) trips have been for her and how in retrospect she fee- oh. Oh. Okay never mind then. We’re not doing that. We’re gonna run around and jump on motorbikes and have action set pieces again. Okay we’re going to have alien baddies who just appear and do nothing but be obtrusive for both the Doctor and ME because they’re genuinely just an annoying non-presence in the story. They’re here to be baddies for the sake of being baddies, and on top of that, they’re woefully uninteresting, sorry not sorry. I can see an idea there, but they’re so laughably underdeveloped (they’re LITERALLY in a total of 15 panels! That’s including when they’re unspeaking dots on the page!) that I barely remember that they’re there. They don’t seem to belong. Even visually, they look like they were designed to be as unappealing as possible, the type of beast you would find in a chocolate egg, and would think interesting of for only a few minutes, but also didn’t want to throw away because it was a little green alien, but also, your guardian was right, and you should probably have. These goombas have so little story presence that I’m baffled they even took the time to include them! I don’t know what they do! I don’t know why Morrison thought for even a second that they were more interesting than the flying space sound whales! Who also to be fair, don’t actually have anything to them!
But actually, the worst thing is that I do know! You know what they’re here for? You know why they annoy me so much? Like I said, the aliens are a nuisance, because they’re not the point of the story, the story isn’t about them, they don’t add anything. They’re here to slow down the plot, and get action scenes. That’s it. There’s a paper thin plot, and it’s thickened up by slowing the main characters down with little green men, and purple and pink fish. It’s filler in a 22 page long comic book. And, if you would excuse me my wording, I think that’s completely f**king ridiculous.
And then we get a really dumb ending where the Doctor tries to teach us a life lesson okay thank you for that made up moral now your story has meaning now it’s good im sure wowszie the Doc and Gabs are gonna talk finally oh the end oh that was it yeah.
Nonexistent story with great ideas in there somewhere. No desires seemingly to add anything here, just to fill 22 pages. That’s just a bit of a bummer. Like we could’ve had such cool stuff here! But oh well. We won’t have to encounter Morrison in this run of comics anymore, so hopefully I’ll take more of a liking to the next ones again!
Owen
View profile
Not a member? Join for free! Forgot password?
Content