Skip to content
TARDIS Guide

Review of Doctor Who: The Day of the Doctor by MrColdStream

11 December 2024

This review contains spoilers!

📝10/10

Thworping through time and space, one adventure at a time!

"Moffat's Day: A Novel Take on a Timeless Tale"

Steven Moffat takes his The Day of the Doctor script and spins it into a novelisation brimming with charm, creativity, and cheeky wit. He opens with a playful introduction, speaking directly to the reader as if narrating live, setting the tone for an inventive reimagining. Not content to simply retell the TV special, Moffat weaves in The Night of the Doctor (fully expanded) and scrambles the story's structure, letting readers choose between following the narrative chronologically or by its intentionally jumbled chapter numbers.

While staying true to the original plot, Moffat enriches the story with deeper character exploration, adding emotional layers and nuanced backstories. His signature humor shines throughout, with clever nods to Doctor Who’s 50-year history—ranging from Peter Cushing's Doctor to Ian Chesterton as Coal Hill’s governor. Even minor characters like McGillop and Atkins get moments in the spotlight, while Kate and Osgood enjoy significant development. Osgood’s awkward genius and budding feelings for McGillop are beautifully fleshed out, and Queen Elizabeth is given a sharper, wittier edge compared to her TV counterpart.

Moffat’s flair for the unexpected is on full display. A standout sequence involves the Doctor discussing Zygons while lounging in a bathtub with River Song, a scene both hilarious and illuminating. The book also switches perspectives and narrative styles, keeping things fresh: a chapter told through Osgood’s letter-writing, and another replaying the Tower dungeon scene from the viewpoints of all three Doctors, digging into their emotional states.

The climax at the barn is similarly expanded, as is the epic multi-Doctor Gallifrey-saving sequence, now featuring a longer Twelfth Doctor cameo. Moffat adds layers of storytelling through “Doctor Papers”—snarky interludes that frame the novel as a lecture, complete with meta commentary and sly challenges for the reader (don’t look for Chapter 9—it doesn’t exist). The eventual reveal of the commentator as the Curator is a delightful touch, and the much-hyped “Chapter 9 gag” is worth the wait.

Moffat peppers the novel with sly references, suggesting the monochrome world of the First and Second Doctors might be due to color blindness or hinting that Susan could be Queen Elizabeth I’s granddaughter. Even the final twist—a poignant scene between the Doctor and Cass—delivers a jaw-dropping reveal: this Doctor is none other than the Thirteenth.

This isn’t just a novelisation; it’s a celebration of Doctor Who’s legacy, brimming with heart, humor, and surprises. For fans, it’s an absolute treasure.